Apartments in Bay Shore, NY under $2,400 (50 Rentals)

list
map
Sort by price

1 to 2 bedrooms $1,845 to $2,150

Fairfield Saxon Arms Apartments
Family Friendly 3.0 Stars
Family Friendly
Kitchen Options
Pet Friendly
Apartment Unit For Rent

Fairfield Saxon Arms Apartments

16 N Saxon Ave Bay Shore, NY 11706
(631) 892-3061 check availability

1 to 2 bedrooms $1,825 to $2,400

Greymore Flats Apartments
Kitchen Options 3.5 Stars
Kitchen Options
Apartment Unit For Rent

Greymore Flats Apartments

19 N Clinton Ave Bay Shore, NY 11706
(631) 215-3181 check availability

2 bedrooms $1,795

1745 N Gardiner Dr Bay Shore NY Apartments
Apartment Unit For Rent

1745 N Gardiner Dr Bay Shore NY Apartments

1745 N Gardiner Dr Bay Shore, NY 11706
Baths Sq.Ft. min Deposit Date Available Lease Length
Description
Amenities
    Contact Details
    Address:
    (631) 983-4977 check availability

    2 bedrooms $1,695

    1747 N Gardiner Dr Bay Shore NY Apartments
    Apartment Unit For Rent

    1747 N Gardiner Dr Bay Shore NY Apartments

    1747 N Gardiner Dr Bay Shore, NY 11706
    Baths Sq.Ft. min Deposit Date Available Lease Length
    Description
    Amenities
      Contact Details
      Address:
      (631) 253-1033 check availability

      1 to 2 bedrooms $1,525 to $1,950

      Bay Shore Manor Apartments
      Family Friendly 3.0 Stars
      Family Friendly
      Kitchen Options
      Outdoors
      Apartment Unit For Rent

      Bay Shore Manor Apartments

      2 Garfield St Bay Shore, NY 11706
      (516) 226-0653 check availability

      1 to 2 bedrooms $1,450 to $2,000

      Newbrook Gardens Apartments
      Kitchen Options 3.5 Stars
      Kitchen Options
      Apartment Unit For Rent

      Newbrook Gardens Apartments

      87 Newbrook Ln Bay Shore, NY 11706
      (631) 983-2135 check availability

      Studio to 2 bedrooms $1,360 to $2,605

      Mid-Island Apartments
      Pet Friendly 3.0 Stars
      Pet Friendly
      Apartment Unit For Rent

      Mid-Island Apartments

      35 Penataquit Ave Bay Shore, NY 11706
      (844) 492-4987 check availability

      2 bedrooms $1,950

      68 Westwood Ave Deer Park NY Apartments
      Apartment Unit For Rent

      68 Westwood Ave Deer Park NY Apartments

      68 Westwood Ave Deer Park, NY 11729
      Baths Sq.Ft. min Deposit Date Available Lease Length
      Description
      Amenities
        Contact Details
        Address:
        (844) 845-0790 check availability

        Studio to 2 Beds $1,690 to $2,285

        Somerset Village Apartments
        Kitchen Options 3.0 Stars
        Kitchen Options
        Pet Friendly
        Apartment Unit For Rent

        Somerset Village Apartments

        1593 August Rd North Babylon, NY 11703
        (866) 620-4381 check availability

        Studio to 3 Beds $1,516 to $2,485

        Hawthorne Court Apartments
        Outdoors 3.5 Stars
        Outdoors
        Apartment Unit For Rent

        Hawthorne Court Apartments

        211 Hawthorne Ave Central Islip, NY 11722
        (866) 505-1581 check availability

        3 bedrooms $2,375

        1639 N Gardiner Dr Bay Shore NY Apartments
        Apartment Unit For Rent

        1639 N Gardiner Dr Bay Shore NY Apartments

        1639 N Gardiner Dr Bay Shore, NY 11706
        Baths Sq.Ft. min Deposit Date Available Lease Length
        Description
        Amenities
          Contact Details
          Address:
          (877) 207-7699

          1 bedroom $2,200

          Guastavino House Apartments
          Apartment Unit For Rent

          Guastavino House Apartments

          143 Awixa Ave Bay Shore, NY 11706
          (844) 835-3695

          1 bedroom $1,500

          The Commons Apartments
          Apartment Unit For Rent

          The Commons Apartments

          28 5th Ave Bay Shore, NY 11706
          (855) 530-8922

          1 bedroom $1,500

          Stone Water Gardens Apartments
          Apartment Unit For Rent

          Stone Water Gardens Apartments

          105 Howells Rd Bay Shore, NY 11706
          (201) 368-5900

          1 bedroom $1,470

          Brookwood at Bay Shore Apartments
          Apartment Unit For Rent

          Brookwood at Bay Shore Apartments

          99 S Clinton Ave Bay Shore, NY 11706
          (844) 695-3478

          Studio $1,000

          177 2nd Ave Bay Shore NY Apartments
          Apartment Unit For Rent

          177 2nd Ave Bay Shore NY Apartments

          177 2nd Ave Bay Shore, NY 11706
          Baths Sq.Ft. min Deposit Date Available Lease Length
          Description
          Amenities
            Contact Details
            Address:
            (877) 214-8366
            Showing 1-50
            Neighborhood Info
            Apartments for rent in Bay Shore, NY

            How much does it cost to rent an apartment in Bay Shore?

            Bedrooms Average Rent Cheapest Rent Highest Rent
            Studio Apartments $1,579 $1,417 $1,995
            1 Bedroom Apartments $1,727 $1,250 $2,325
            2 Bedroom Apartments $2,103 $1,600 $2,795
            3 Bedroom Apartments $2,631 $2,450 $2,795

            Apartments for Rent in Nearby Cities

            1 to 2 bedrooms $1,845 to $2,150

            Fairfield Saxon Arms Apartments
            Family Friendly 3.0 Stars
            Family Friendly
            Kitchen Options
            Pet Friendly
            Apartment Unit For Rent

            Fairfield Saxon Arms Apartments

            16 N Saxon Ave Bay Shore, NY 11706
            Baths Sq.Ft. min Deposit Date Available Lease Length
            Description
            Amenities
              Contact Details
              Address:
              (631) 892-3061 check availability
              See All Bay Shore Apartments (132)