Apartments in Bay Shore, NY under $2,400 (45 Rentals)

1 to 2 bedrooms $1,845 to $2,150

Fairfield Saxon Arms Apartments
Family Friendly
Family Friendly
Kitchen Options
Pet Friendly
Apartment Unit For Rent

Fairfield Saxon Arms Apartments

16 N Saxon Ave Bay Shore, NY 11706
(631) 892-3061 check availability

1 to 2 bedrooms $1,825 to $2,400

Greymore Flats Apartments
Kitchen Options
Kitchen Options
Apartment Unit For Rent

Greymore Flats Apartments

19 N Clinton Ave Bay Shore, NY 11706
(631) 215-3181 check availability

1 to 2 bedrooms $1,750 to $2,450

Chelsea Place Apartments
Cost Per Sq.Ft.
Cost Per Sq.Ft.
Kitchen Options
Apartment Unit For Rent

Chelsea Place Apartments

102-124 Railroad Plz Bay Shore, NY 11706
(844) 346-5085 check availability

1 to 2 bedrooms $1,750 to $1,925

12 Shore Ln Apartments
Pet Friendly
Pet Friendly
Apartment Unit For Rent

12 Shore Ln Apartments

12 Shore Ln Bay Shore, NY 11706
(844) 342-4709 check availability

1 to 2 bedrooms $1,725 to $2,150

Greenview Gardens Apartments
Outdoors
Outdoors
Apartment Unit For Rent

Greenview Gardens Apartments

18 Debora Ct Bay Shore, NY 11706
(844) 619-8920 check availability

1 to 2 Beds $1,720 to $2,175

Fairfield Eastbrook Gardens Apartments
Kitchen Options
Kitchen Options
Pet Friendly
Apartment Unit For Rent

Fairfield Eastbrook Gardens Apartments

327 Brook Ave Bay Shore, NY 11706
(877) 662-7486 check availability

1 to 2 Beds $1,700 to $2,025

Fairfield Tudor At Bay Shore Apartments
Cost Per Sq.Ft.
Cost Per Sq.Ft.
Pet Friendly
Apartment Unit For Rent

Fairfield Tudor At Bay Shore Apartments

72-78 S Clinton Ave Bay Shore, NY 11706
(631) 256-4503 check availability

1 to 2 bedrooms $1,525 to $1,950

Bay Shore Manor Apartments
Family Friendly
Family Friendly
Kitchen Options
Outdoors
Apartment Unit For Rent

Bay Shore Manor Apartments

2 Garfield St Bay Shore, NY 11706
(516) 226-0653 check availability

1 to 2 bedrooms $1,507 to $2,450

Chatham Square Apartments
Cost Per Sq.Ft.
Cost Per Sq.Ft.
Kitchen Options
Apartment Unit For Rent

Chatham Square Apartments

2-31 Charley's Pl Bay Shore, NY 11706
(877) 839-6653 check availability

Studio to 1 bedroom $1,500 to $1,800

5 Shore Loft at Bay Shore Apartments
Pet Friendly
Pet Friendly
Apartment Unit For Rent

5 Shore Loft at Bay Shore Apartments

5 Shore Ln Bay Shore, NY 11706
(844) 334-5809 check availability

Studio to 2 bedrooms $1,486 to $2,906

Mid-Island Apartments
Pet Friendly
Pet Friendly
Apartment Unit For Rent

Mid-Island Apartments

35 Penataquit Ave Bay Shore, NY 11706
(844) 492-4987 check availability

1 to 2 Beds $1,450 to $1,600

Oakwood Manor Senior Community Apartments
Cost Per Sq.Ft.
Cost Per Sq.Ft.
Pet Friendly
Entertainment Options
Apartment Unit For Rent

Oakwood Manor Senior Community Apartments

700 Justine Ct Bay Shore, NY 11706
(844) 638-8881 check availability

Studio to 2 bedrooms $1,407 to $2,150

Village Place Apartments
Kitchen Options
Kitchen Options
Apartment Unit For Rent

Village Place Apartments

61 W Main St Bay Shore, NY 11706
(914) 372-6277 check availability

Studio to 2 Beds $1,325

Bayshore Garden Apartments
Apartment Unit For Rent

Bayshore Garden Apartments

413-429 E Main St Bay Shore, NY 11706
(631) 206-6814 check availability

Studio to 1 Beds $1,550 to $1,695

Fairfield At The Village Of Brightwaters Apartments
Kitchen Options
Kitchen Options
Pet Friendly
Apartment Unit For Rent

Fairfield At The Village Of Brightwaters Apartments

140 Orinoco Dr Brightwaters, NY 11718
(631) 892-2033 check availability

Studio to 2 bedrooms $1,995 to $3,450

Meridian Lofts Apartments
Kitchen Options
Kitchen Options
Apartment Unit For Rent

Meridian Lofts Apartments

16 Willow Ave Islip, NY 11751
(844) 305-1043 check availability

1 to 2 Beds $1,725 to $2,200

Greenview Village Senior 55+ Apartments
Family Friendly
Family Friendly
Outdoors
Pet Friendly
Entertainment Options
Apartment Unit For Rent

Greenview Village Senior 55+ Apartments

465 Chelsea Dr Islip, NY 11751
(877) 875-2466 check availability

Studio to 3 Beds $1,595 to $2,795

Fairfield Arnold Manor At West Islip Apartments
Pet Friendly
Pet Friendly
Apartment Unit For Rent

Fairfield Arnold Manor At West Islip Apartments

1001 Montauk Hwy West Islip, NY 11795
(844) 712-7440 check availability

1 to 2 bedrooms $1,960 to $2,400

Fairfield At Deer Park Apartments
Kitchen Options
Kitchen Options
Pet Friendly
Apartment Unit For Rent

Fairfield At Deer Park Apartments

766 Nicolls Rd Deer Park, NY 11729
(516) 531-7250 check availability

1 to 2 Beds $1,805 to $2,375

Fairfield Courtyard At Deer Park Apartments
Kitchen Options
Kitchen Options
Pet Friendly
Apartment Unit For Rent

Fairfield Courtyard At Deer Park Apartments

1 Golden Ave Deer Park, NY 11729
(516) 473-0967 check availability

Studio to 2 Beds $1,690 to $2,285

Somerset Village Apartments
Kitchen Options
Kitchen Options
Pet Friendly
Apartment Unit For Rent

Somerset Village Apartments

1593 August Rd North Babylon, NY 11703
(866) 620-4381 check availability

Studio to 1 bedroom $1,610 to $1,730

Fairfield At Islip Terrace Apartments
Kitchen Options
Kitchen Options
Pet Friendly
Apartment Unit For Rent

Fairfield At Islip Terrace Apartments

118 Carleton Ave Islip Terrace, NY 11752
(631) 206-6366 check availability

1 Beds $1,560

Maple Crest Garden Apartments at Dix Hills
Pet Friendly
Pet Friendly
Apartment Unit For Rent

Maple Crest Garden Apartments at Dix Hills

21 Baldwin Path Deer Park, NY 11729
(866) 505-0490 check availability

Studio to 2 bedrooms $1,510 to $1,915

Fairfield Station At Deer Park Apartments
Pet Friendly
Pet Friendly
Apartment Unit For Rent

Fairfield Station At Deer Park Apartments

801 Long Island Ave Deer Park, NY 11729
(516) 342-5314 check availability

1 bedroom $1,200 to $1,250

Manor Park Apartments Senior Community 55+
Cost Per Sq.Ft.
Cost Per Sq.Ft.
Apartment Unit For Rent

Manor Park Apartments Senior Community 55+

215 Carlls Path Deer Park, NY 11729
(844) 670-6018 check availability

1 bedroom $1,840 to $1,935

Fairfield Harbor At Babylon Village Apartments
Kitchen Options
Kitchen Options
Pet Friendly
Apartment Unit For Rent

Fairfield Harbor At Babylon Village Apartments

99 Prospect St Babylon, NY 11702
(631) 865-0814 check availability

1 to 2 Beds $1,730 to $2,450

Fairfield Park At Babylon Village Apartments
Kitchen Options
Kitchen Options
Pet Friendly
Apartment Unit For Rent

Fairfield Park At Babylon Village Apartments

100 Friendly Ct Babylon, NY 11702
(866) 216-9697 check availability

Studio to 3 Beds $1,550 to $2,485

Hawthorne Court Apartments
Outdoors
Outdoors
Apartment Unit For Rent

Hawthorne Court Apartments

211 Hawthorne Ave Central Islip, NY 11722
(866) 505-1581 check availability

1 bedroom $2,200

Guastavino House Apartments
Apartment Unit For Rent

Guastavino House Apartments

143 Awixa Ave Bay Shore, NY 11706
check availability

2 bedrooms $1,795

1729 N Gardiner Dr Bay Shore NY Apartments
Apartment Unit For Rent

1729 N Gardiner Dr Bay Shore NY Apartments

1729 N Gardiner Dr Bay Shore, NY 11706
Baths Sq.Ft. min Deposit Date Available Lease Length
Description
Amenities
    Contact Details
    Address:
    (844) 519-1679 check availability

    1 to 2 bedrooms $1,785 to $2,250

    Fairfield North At Bay Shore Apartments
    Apartment Unit For Rent

    Fairfield North At Bay Shore Apartments

    25 N Clinton Ave Bay Shore, NY 11706
    check availability

    2 bedrooms $1,770

    Brookwood at Bay Shore Apartments
    Apartment Unit For Rent

    Brookwood at Bay Shore Apartments

    99 S Clinton Ave Bay Shore, NY 11706
    check availability

    1 to 2 bedrooms $1,765 to $2,150

    Fairfield South At Bay Shore Apartments
    Apartment Unit For Rent

    Fairfield South At Bay Shore Apartments

    53 S Clinton Ave Bay Shore, NY 11706
    check availability

    2 bedrooms $1,750

    62 E Main St Bay Shore NY Apartments
    Apartment Unit For Rent

    62 E Main St Bay Shore NY Apartments

    62 E Main St Bay Shore, NY 11706
    Baths Sq.Ft. min Deposit Date Available Lease Length
    Description
    Amenities
      Contact Details
      Address:
      check availability

      1 to 2 bedrooms $1,735 to $2,150

      Fairfield Gardens At Bay Shore Apartments
      Apartment Unit For Rent

      Fairfield Gardens At Bay Shore Apartments

      64 S Clinton Ave Bay Shore, NY 11706
      check availability

      1 to 2 bedrooms $1,735 to $2,150

      Fairfield Arms at Bay Shore Apartments
      Apartment Unit For Rent

      Fairfield Arms at Bay Shore Apartments

      80 S Clinton Ave Bay Shore, NY 11706
      check availability

      1 bedroom $1,650

      Newbrook Gardens Apartments
      Apartment Unit For Rent

      Newbrook Gardens Apartments

      87 Newbrook Ln Bay Shore, NY 11706
      check availability

      1 bedroom $1,635

      Fairfield Renaissance Apartments
      Apartment Unit For Rent

      Fairfield Renaissance Apartments

      55 5th Ave Bay Shore, NY 11706
      check availability

      1 to 2 bedrooms $1,570 to $1,920

      Fairfield West At Bay Shore Apartments
      Apartment Unit For Rent

      Fairfield West At Bay Shore Apartments

      241 W Main St Bay Shore, NY 11706
      check availability

      Studio to 2 bedrooms $1,570 to $2,215

      Fairfield On The Lake Apartments
      Apartment Unit For Rent

      Fairfield On The Lake Apartments

      3-15 Willowbrook Ave Bay Shore, NY 11706
      check availability

      2 bedrooms $1,850

      Brookwood at Islip Garden Apartments
      Apartment Unit For Rent

      Brookwood at Islip Garden Apartments

      29 Buffalo Ave Islip, NY 11751
      check availability

      1 to 2 bedrooms $1,800 to $2,175

      Greenview Village Apartments
      Apartment Unit For Rent

      Greenview Village Apartments

      235 Grant Ave Islip, NY 11751
      check availability

      1 bedroom $1,895

      Fairfield At North Babylon Apartments
      Apartment Unit For Rent

      Fairfield At North Babylon Apartments

      751 Deer Park Ave North Babylon, NY 11703
      check availability

      1 to 2 bedrooms $2,225 to $2,795

      Fairfield Townhouses At Babylon Village Apartments
      Apartment Unit For Rent

      Fairfield Townhouses At Babylon Village Apartments

      39-59 Park Ave Babylon, NY 11702
      check availability

      1 to 2 bedrooms $2,170 to $2,570

      Fairfield At Babylon Village Apartments
      Apartment Unit For Rent

      Fairfield At Babylon Village Apartments

      134 Park Ave Babylon, NY 11702
      check availability
      Showing 1-45
      list
      map

      Official Apartments in Bay Shore under $2400 on October 17, 2017. Check availability!

      Neighborhood Info
      Apartments for rent in Bay Shore, NY
      How much does it cost to rent an apartment in Bay Shore?
      Bedrooms Average Rent Cheapest Rent Highest Rent
      Studio Apartments $1,575 $1,325 $1,995
      1 Bedroom Apartments $1,794 $1,200 $2,950
      2 Bedroom Apartments $2,205 $1,600 $3,450
      3 Bedroom Apartments $2,631 $2,450 $2,795
      Hey There!

      We’ve helped thousands of residents find the perfect Apartments in Bay Shore under $2400 by showcasing the best apartments for rent and providing the most detailed information on each one, updated every single day.

      Apartments in Other Nearby Cities

      1 to 2 bedrooms $1,845 to $2,150

      Fairfield Saxon Arms Apartments
      Family Friendly
      Family Friendly
      Kitchen Options
      Pet Friendly
      Apartment Unit For Rent

      Fairfield Saxon Arms Apartments

      16 N Saxon Ave Bay Shore, NY 11706
      Baths Sq.Ft. min Deposit Date Available Lease Length
      Description
      Amenities
        Contact Details
        Address:
        (631) 892-3061 check availability
        See All Bay Shore Apartments (126)

          See Apartments in Bay Shore, New York Neighborhoods (hide all neighborhoods)

          Apartments in Other Nearby Cities

          Back to top

          View Other Local Living Guides...