Mayfair Gardens Apartments in Commack, NY

Contact

Mayfair Gardens

51 Mayfair Gdns
Commack, NY 11725
(631) 406-4899

Studio–2 Bedrooms
$1,850-$2,900 Pricing
400–900 Square Feet

About Mayfair Gardens

The apartment homes at Mayfair Gardens feature an array of modern amenities and many extras for your convenience. Choose from a variety of living spaces designed to meet your every need. You'll be close to transportation, shopping, and great entertainment. Call today to make Mayfair Garden your new home! **NO FEE RENTAL NO SHORT-TERM LEASES. **A Credit Score of 701 or better is required** **Please call first, tours are done by Appointment Only** **NO BROKER FEES, Leasing Team** **We do not accept Co-Signers or Guarantors **

Mayfair Gardens is located in the Commack Neighborhood and 11725 Zip code of Commack, NY. This community is professionally managed by Empire Management

Property Contact Info

Listed by:
Agency:
Vendor Logo:
Website:: View Property Website
Call Us:: (631) 406-4899
Disclaimer:

Ask About Our Move-In Specials

Floorplan Pricing and Availability

Mayfair Gardens offers Studio to 2 Bedroom apartments starting from $1,850 and having 400–900 sq ft. Here is the current pricing and availability:

Studio
1 Bedrooms
2 Bedrooms

Studio
Studio A
Studio, 1 Bath, 400 sq ft
Availability Details
Price Availability Date Unit Sq Ft
$1,850 Call for Availability Studio A 400 sq ft
Model Amenities and Features
Features
Air Conditioning
Cable Ready
Heating
High Speed Internet Access
Smoke Free
Kitchen
Dishwasher
Granite Countertops
Ice Maker
Microwave
Oven
Range
Refrigerator
Stainless Steel Appliances
Model Rent and Fees
Model Price
$1,850
Studio B
Studio, 1 Bath, 500 sq ft
Availability Details
Price Availability Date Unit Sq Ft
$2,000 Call for Availability Studio B 500 sq ft
Model Amenities and Features
Features
Air Conditioning
Cable Ready
Heating
High Speed Internet Access
Smoke Free
Kitchen
Dishwasher
Granite Countertops
Ice Maker
Microwave
Oven
Range
Refrigerator
Stainless Steel Appliances
Model Rent and Fees
Model Price
$2,000
Studio C
Studio, 1 Bath, 600 sq ft

Largest StudioThis is the largest Studio at this Property
Availability Details
Price Availability Date Unit Sq Ft
$2,150 Call for Availability Studio C 600 sq ft
Model Amenities and Features
Features
Air Conditioning
Cable Ready
Heating
High Speed Internet Access
Smoke Free
Kitchen
Dishwasher
Granite Countertops
Ice Maker
Microwave
Oven
Range
Refrigerator
Stainless Steel Appliances
Model Rent and Fees
Model Price
$2,150
1 Bedroom
Sort by
Junior 1 Bedroom
$2,350
1 Bed, 1 Bath, 700 sq ft
Available Now
Availability Details
Price Availability Date Unit Sq Ft
$2,350 Available Now Junior 1 Bedroom 700 sq ft
Model Amenities and Features
Features
Air Conditioning
Cable Ready
Heating
High Speed Internet Access
Smoke Free
Kitchen
Dishwasher
Granite Countertops
Ice Maker
Microwave
Oven
Range
Refrigerator
Stainless Steel Appliances
Model Rent and Fees
Model Price
$2,350
One Bedroom
$2,525
1 Bed, 1 Bath, 750 sq ft
Available Now
Model Gallery
3D Tours
Availability Details
Price Availability Date Unit Sq Ft
$2,525 Available Now One Bedroom 750 sq ft
Model Amenities and Features
Features
High Speed Internet Access
Smoke Free
Model Rent and Fees
Model Price
$2,525
Apartment Model: One Bedroom$2,5251 Bedroom, 1 Bath, 750 sq ftAvailable Now
One Bedroom - 3D Tour
2 Bedrooms
Two Bedroom
2 Beds, 1 Bath, 900 sq ft
Availability Details
Price Availability Date Unit Sq Ft Deposit
$2,900 Call for Availability Two Bedroom 900 sq ft $2,330
Model Amenities and Features
Features
High Speed Internet Access
Smoke Free
Model Rent and Fees
Model Price
$2,900
Deposit
$2,330 deposit

Price	Availability Date	Unit	Sq Ft
$1,850	Call for Availability	Studio A	400 sq ft

Price	Availability Date	Unit	Sq Ft
$2,000	Call for Availability	Studio B	500 sq ft

Price	Availability Date	Unit	Sq Ft
$2,150	Call for Availability	Studio C	600 sq ft

Price	Availability Date	Unit	Sq Ft
$2,350	Available Now	Junior 1 Bedroom	700 sq ft

Price	Availability Date	Unit	Sq Ft
$2,525	Available Now	One Bedroom	750 sq ft

Price	Availability Date	Unit	Sq Ft	Deposit
$2,900	Call for Availability	Two Bedroom	900 sq ft	$2,330

Price shown is base rent. Excludes user-selected optional fees and variable or usage-based fees and required charges due at or prior to move-in or at move-out. View Fees and Policies for details. Price, availability, fees, and any applicable rent special are subject to change without notice.

Schedule a Tour

Request Tour

Call us at: (631) 406-4899 to request a tour.

3D Tours

1BR, 1BA - 750 SF

Property Information

107 Units
2 Stories
Built in 2002

Lease Terms

12 mo

Ask About Our Lease Terms

Fees and Policies

The fees listed below are community-provided and may exclude utilities or add-ons. All payments are made directly to the property and are non-refundable unless otherwise specified.

Ask About Our Fees

Required Fees

One-Time Basics

Administrative Fee$0.00

Application Fee Per Applicant$50.00

Other Fees and Policies

Pet Fees

Cat: Pet DepositiMax of 1. Charged per Pet.$200.00; Monthly Pet FeeiMax of 1. Charged Per Pet.$20.00/mo
Dog: Pet DepositiMax of 1. Charged per Pet.$300.00; Monthly Pet FeeiMax of 1. Charged Per Pet.$35.00/mo

Find Out About Our Pet Policy

Parking Info and Fees

Surface Lot

Property Fee Disclaimer: Based on community-supplied data and independent market research. Subject to change without notice. May exclude fees for mandatory or optional services and usage-based utilities.

Features and Amenities

Unique Amenities

5 Burner Gas range

On-Site Services

Maintenance On Site
Laundry Facilities
Garden

Outdoor Features

Courtyard
Lawn

Interior Features

High Speed Internet Access
Heating
Cable Ready
Air Conditioning
Smoke Free

Kitchen Amenities

Range
Refrigerator
Oven
Dishwasher
Microwave
Stainless Steel Appliances
Ice Maker
Granite Countertops

Living Area Features

Office
Window Coverings
Vaulted Ceiling
Crown Molding
Double Pane Windows
Hardwood Floors

Ask About Our Amenities

Getting Around

50 / 100 Fairly walkable
Some day-to-day needs are within walking distance
0 / 100 Minimal public transit
Few or no transit options
50 / 100 Fairly bikeable
Somewhat suitable for bicycle commuting and/or recreation
80 / 100 Very car friendly
Excellent access to freeways and/or major arteries, with a very low chance of parking problems

Scores provided by

details

Getting to Know the Area

70 / 100 Restaurants
Variety of restaurants within a few minutes
60 / 100 Cafes
Variety of cafés within a few minutes
60 / 100 Nightlife
Several bars within a few minutes
60 / 100 Shopping
Several shops within a few minutes
80 / 100 Noise Level
Very few sources of noise nearby

Scores provided by

Frequently Asked Questions about Mayfair Gardens

Where is Mayfair Gardens located?

Mayfair Gardens is located at 51 Mayfair Gdns near the Commack area of Commack, NY

What is the current rent range at Mayfair Gardens?

Studio to 2 Bedroom Apartments at Mayfair Gardens currently range from $1,850 to $2,900

Are pets allowed?

Call us today to find out our pet policy and if we allow pets

Renters Reviews and Ratings

2.8

21 Renters Reviews

Sort by

Showing 1-12 of 21 Reviews

Great Experience

August 21, 2023 - Review from Apartments.com

I moved here after my grandmother lived here a few years back. The apartments were clean and well kept. Both Lois & Jimmy made the entire experience great and at an affordable price too! I highly recommend Mayfair Gardens

5 Year Tenant - Pleasant Experience

December 1, 2021 - Review from Apartments.com

I have lived at Mayfair Gardens for 5 years and have enjoyed it very much. The grounds are kept clean, the staff is very friendly/helpful, and it has all of the amenities. Location is great with groceries, restaurants, and everything you could want within a mile or so. Pathways were always cleared quickly when it snowed and the parking lots were plowed as well. Whenever I had an issue it was resolved quickly and I was provided with updates. I recommend this property to anybody who is looking for ...

an apartment!

It’s Okay.

September 25, 2021 - Review from Apartments.com

If you want to live in a place where no residents care about each other’s vehicles, this is the place. The number of dings on the sides of my car that regularly occur is horrendous. Management also allows vehicles with no license plates to take up parking spots in the lot for months on end. With that said, the apartments are in good condition and reasonably sized.

Leasing Agent is very rude

May 3, 2021 - Review from Apartments.com

The leasing agent for this property completely turned me off from renting here. Extremely rude and won't answer questions without an attitude.

The management company is severely lacking in communication.

July 22, 2020 - Review from Apartments.com

The management company is miserable to work with. Looking at google reviews for the company shows that I am not alone in this. It has been 3 months since I left the apartment, and I have yet to receive my security deposit. I did the final walk-through with the superintendent where they found nothing wrong with the apartment. I have written them letters, called, and emailed them numerous times, most of the time I don't even get a response. The only time they contacted me was to get my new address ...

(even though I already gave it to the super during the walk-through) and they assured me that they would be sending out the check that day. That was a month ago, still no check, still no update. The apartment itself isn't that bad, though the price is very high for the complete lack of amenities. I honestly probably would have given it 3 stars if it wasn't for the hassle trying to get the security deposit. Also, just an FYI, as of April of 2020 the only way they accepted rent payments was to mail them a physical check...

Great 1 bedroom apartment!

April 11, 2020 - Review from Apartments.com

My wife and I lived here for almost 4 years and we just recently moved to a house. Our time at Mayfair was great. The location is perfect, right across the street from all the essentials and very close to the highway. The apartment itself is very modern, with updated appliances, wood floors, and fixtures. The people in the complex are also incredibly friendly, especially the super, Jimmy, who lives in the building we were in. He was always incredibly friendly and whenever we had an issue, he was ...

quick to respond. One time in particular, our heat was not working, he immediately came to our apartment and did everything he could that night to make sure it was up and running. We were actually living here before Jimmy took over as super, and I cannot stress what an upgrade it has been having Jimmy around. Overall, living here was a great experience and we would absolutely recommend it!

1 year at Mayfair Gardens

November 1, 2019 - Review from Apartments.com

Enjoyed my time here in a very spacious 1 bedroom apartment. Apartment was recently fully redone on the inside. Jimmy the super was great. Always responded quickly - i even locked myself out and he was able to get me in. I already miss this place.

31 Mayfair garden Commack ny

October 12, 2019 - Review from Apartments.com

Rented a 1 bedroom apartment. Brand new kitchen loved living here all this months neighbors are very nice! Jimmy the supper is amazing he helps you at anytime and whatever needs to get done he does it!!! every time I needed something in my apartment it was fix an done!! the buildingS are kept and save smoking free. Clean laundry rooms are Available on premises. There is parking all the time. Highly recommend if your looking for a new place to live this is the place to be. Lois is great at her job ...

an works fast on getting all your paperwork together to make you move fast an easy!! Love living here.

Unpleasant Experience

July 29, 2017 - Review from Apartments.com

We've spent 15 months at Mayfair Gardens since 10/14/2015 & our experience was far from excellent. The outer façade was updated, inside of the buildings not so much. As advertised the rooms consist of modern amenities; two bedrooms, fair closet storage, wood floors, cherry wood kitchen cabinets with stainless steel appliances, full bathroom, but that’s where the positives end. Tenants don't have control over the heating in their rooms; it is excruciatingly hot to the point where you have to open ...

a window, especially in the winter & we had ours open during one blizzard. We mentioned about the heat to the super & said within the year that the issue would be resolved (15 months later nothing has changed). Early 2016 the cesspool backed up & made a huge mess on the floor. That was particularly disgusting because one of the machines was still filled with cesspool liquid & ultimately forced us to go to the laundromat. The exterminator comes twice a month. To find out from the exterminator that other tenants have bugs in their apartment & they came from their rooms into ours is unsettling to say the least. We weren’t happy with the response time & communication. No post on the bulletin board about the cesspool issue as well as being up to date with having it fixed. When the vacant apartments needed to renovated we wouldn’t be notified of such notice. Waking up to noise around 7 a.m, unannounced, isn’t the way to conduct business. A heads up the day before would’ve been appreciated. Once unannounced they turned off the water. Parking is insufficient if you live further away from the lot, leaving you to park on the street by the sidewalk, if you’re lucky enough to get a spot near your building. The gate to the back entrance is locked up at night because management doesn’t want outsiders to use the trash bins. Downside is that it makes it inconvenient for tenants who live right near those buildings to park. Not all the tenants were considerate. Most of time we heard stomping from the people living above us. Twice they blasted their music at an unacceptable level that we hear it from downstairs. Day/Night we would hear the doors slam. We've spoken to the super about these issues but he either look at us with disbelief or shrugged it off. It’s not handicap accessible. Lastly it would be best you have things for your kids to do/play with because there is not much to do there. Long story short Mayfair Gardens wasn’t a positive experience for us.

Property Manager Responded

August 1, 2017

Management is sorry that you had a bad experience, if only you would have contacted management or wrote us an email or picked up the phone to let us now the troubles you were having. Only telling the super and not letting upper management aware could have help you. We have replaced the prior super with a new one because we were unhappy the way he attended to our tenants. As far as the heat goes we are under contract and started the boiler replacement starting this August, we would have liked to of done it sooner but wanted it to happen during the summer month when heat is not needed. As far as water shutting off sometimes there are emergency's that happen and we have no chose, if we know we have something to do we do put up notices the day before we plan on doing work. To All reading this, we Management take great pride it what this complex looks like and want everyone of our tenants to be happy, if you live hear and have a concern please let us know.

Mayfair Gardens, Commack, NY

March 21, 2017 - Review from Apartments.com

We have been here since October, 2016 and could not be any happier with the apartment. Our two bedroom updated apartment is equipped with modern amenities, our kitchen is beautiful and the closet/storeage space is outstanding. The parking is ample and during this snowy winter the maintenance did a great job removing the snow from the walks, parking lot and laundry areas. Lois, the leasing agent is wonderful to work with! She is "hands on" in all aspects. If every a question or concern ...

arises, I can text her and she immediately responds. Lois makes us feel as though we are living in an exclusive apartment with personal attention without the pricey rent. We would recommend the Mayfair Gardens in Commack, NY to both families and single occupants.

Brand New and lovely place to call home!

August 1, 2016 - Review from Apartments.com

Moved in two months ago and it's been terrific! Our very bright and spacious 2-bedroom apartment with soaring ceilings is brand new and modern with wood floors, a cherry wood kitchen with stainless steel appliances and beautiful countertops, an all new full bathroom and closets galore! The grounds are beautiful too and the laundry rooms are clean and always available! In the highly-rated Commack School District, Mayfair Gardens is a lovely place we call home!

They Are Trying

June 22, 2016 - Review from Apartments.com

I lived there for three years. The previous property manager was too busy to properly take care of the property, because he also had properties in New York City to take care of, but Angelo and Lois have worked hard to address whatever issues come up. I only moved due to a financial problem (job loss). The Super, Mike is available on the cell phone and will call you back or come in an emergency. Since Angelo and Lois are now managing the property, the Super has scheduled maintenance repair ...

work, so you may have to wait if yours is not an emergency and he is dealing with an emergency situation. You can send maintenance requests online, drop one in the mailbox outside the rental office and call in an emergency. Some of the bldgs. need more renovating for infrastructure, but as long as you ask and follow up with them, they will try to fix things. The buildings are old, for each apartment that was renovated on the inside, they removed everything down to the frame, they gutted kitchens, bathrooms (entirely), bedrooms and living rooms. Give them a little more time to get it up to the standards you expect. I previously lived at Heatherwood, every bldg. in the complex I lived in had plumbing problems (backups), in the three years I was there, they did not resolve them. Mine was only resolved because I lived above one of the maintenance offices and I called Ray the plumber and paid him myself to get mine fixed.

Smithtown Elementary School

Smithtown Central School District

51 Lawrence Avenue

Public School - Grades K-5 (517 Students)

Located Nearby8 minute drive / 4.1 miles away

Property Identified

Northport Middle School

Northport-East Northport Union Free School District

11 Middleville Road

Public School - Grades K-8 (694 Students)

Located Nearby9 minute drive / 4.6 miles away

Property Identified

Smithtown High School West

Smithtown Central School District

100 Central Road

Public School - Grades 9-12 (1158 Students)

Located Nearby5 minute drive / 1.9 miles away

Property Identified

School data provided by GreatSchools.

Points of Interest

Time and distance from Mayfair Gardens.

Big Box and Retail

Target

98 Veterans Memorial Hwy

3 minute drive / 1.17 miles away

Staples

5001-5003 Jericho Tpke

4 minute drive / 2.32 miles away

Kohl's

45 Crooked Hill Rd

5 minute drive / 2.72 miles away

Groceries

Shoprite

1 Garet Pl

6 minute drive / 3.08 miles away

Trader Joe's

2085 New Moriches Rd

16 minute drive / 7.53 miles away

Mayfair Gardens has 5 shopping centers within 1.1 miles.

Rental Price Ranges in the Area

Bedroom	Average Rent	Cheapest Rent	Highest Rent
Commack Studio Apartments	$2,147	$1,850	$2,290
Commack 1 Bedroom Apartments	$2,689	$1,600	$3,200
Commack 2 Bedroom Apartments	$3,463	$2,300	$6,400
Commack 3 Bedroom Apartments	$3,733	$3,500	$4,200
Commack 4 Bedroom Apartments	$3,783	$3,783	$3,783
2 Bedroom Homes	$3,366	$2,350	$5,000
3 Bedroom Homes	$4,020	$3,350	$4,600
4 Bedroom Homes	$5,903	$4,300	$9,500
5 Bedroom Homes	$4,875	$3,750	$6,000
6 Bedroom Homes	$6,700	$6,200	$7,200
7 Bedroom Homes	$7,500	$7,500	$7,500

Browse Top Apartments in Commack

By Price

By Community Type

By Amenities

Viewing: Mayfair Gardens | Desktop Version | Listing Updated: 05/29/2026 | AHLPLA

Mayfair Gardens Apartments

Share on Social

Contact

Mayfair Gardens

About Mayfair Gardens

Property Contact Info

Floorplan Pricing and Availability

New! Interactive Property Map

Studio

Studio A

Availability Details

Model Amenities and Features

Features

Kitchen

Model Rent and Fees

Model Price

Studio B

Availability Details

Model Amenities and Features

Features

Kitchen

Model Rent and Fees

Model Price

Studio C

Availability Details

Model Amenities and Features

Features

Kitchen

Model Rent and Fees

Model Price

1 Bedroom

Junior 1 Bedroom

$2,350

Availability Details

Model Amenities and Features

Features

Kitchen

Model Rent and Fees

Model Price

One Bedroom

$2,525

Model Gallery

3D Tours

Availability Details

Model Amenities and Features

Features

Model Rent and Fees

Model Price

2 Bedrooms

Two Bedroom

Availability Details

Model Amenities and Features

Features

Model Rent and Fees

Model Price

Deposit

Property Map

Property Map

Schedule a Tour

3D Tours

Property Information

Lease Terms

Fees and Policies

Required Fees

One-Time Basics

Other Fees and Policies

Pet Fees

Parking Info and Fees

Features and Amenities

Unique Amenities

On-Site Services

Outdoor Features

Interior Features

Kitchen Amenities

Living Area Features

Map

Map

Getting Around

50 / 100 Fairly walkable

0 / 100 Minimal public transit