Your message has been sent! Thank you!

Mid Island Apartments

Verified
This is a CoStar Verified® Listing

Mid Island Apartments in Bay Shore, NY is verified by CoStar’s® proprietary screening and fraud detection process, so you can shop and rent with confidence on ApartmentHomeLiving.com. Always protect yourself when shopping online.

(934) 333-5378
Check Availability
35 Penataquit Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706
Building Photo
Building Photo
18 Photos11 Floorplans4 3D Tours
Building Photo
Building Photo
Building Photo
Building Photo
Building Photo
Building Photo
Building Photo
Building Photo
18 Photos11 Floorplans4 3D Tours

Contact

Mid Island Apartments

35 Penataquit Ave
Bay Shore, NY 11706
(934) 333-5378
Mid Island Apartments in Bay Shore, NY - Building Photo
  • Studio–2 Bedrooms
  • $2,070-$3,180 Pricing
  • 400–915 Square Feet

About Mid Island Apartments

Mid Island Apartments is more than just a place to call home. Our quality studio, one, and two-bedroom apartment homes have been upgraded to match your lifestyle. This quaint community, built with traditional brick architecture, is surrounded by expansive green courtyards and tucked into the historic Bay Shore neighborhood on Long Island, New York. Our recently remodeled, pet-friendly homes feature hardwood flooring, and stainless-steel appliances. Enticing outdoor adventure, delicious dining options, charming coffee shops, and highly rated schools are just minutes from Mid Island Apartments.

Mid Island Apartments is located in the Downtown Bay Shore Neighborhood and 11706 Zip code of Bay Shore, NY. This community is professionally managed by Eagle Rock Management

Unique Features and Amenities

  • Air Conditioner
  • Clean Air Living
  • Community Playground
  • Dishwasher
  • Dishwasher (In Select Apartment Homes)
  • Hardwood Flooring (In Select Apartment Homes)
  • High or Vaulted Ceilings in Select Apartments
  • Laundry Facility
  • Microwave
  • Newly Renovated Apartment Homes
  • Newly Renovated Apartment Homes (In Select Apartment Homes)
  • Open Lot Parking
  • Pet Friendly - Some Restrictions Apply
  • Stainless Steel Appliances
  • Stainless Steel Appliances (In Select Apartment Homes)
  • Thermal-pane Windows in Select Apartments
  • Walk-In Closets (In Select Apartment Homes)
  • Washer/dryer
  • Washer/Dryer (In Select Apartment Homes)

See All Amenities

Property Contact Info

View Property Website
Call Us:
(934) 333-5378
Ask About Our Move-In Specials

Office Hours

Monday9:00 am–5:30 pm
Tuesday9:00 am–5:30 pm
Wednesday9:00 am–5:30 pm
Thursday9:00 am–5:30 pm
Friday9:00 am–5:30 pm
Saturday9:00 am–5:30 pm
SundayClosed

Floorplan Pricing and Availability

Mid Island Apartments offers Studio to 2 Bedroom apartments starting from $2,070 and having 400–915 sq ft. Here is the current pricing and availability:

Cost CalculatorEstimate your monthly and one-time fees

  • Studio

    Floorplan S1

    From $2,070

    Studio, 1 Bath, 400 sq ft
    Available Now

    Model Gallery

    Floorplans

    Availability Details

    PriceAvailability DateUnitSq FtView Details
    $2,150Available Now0551C400
    $2,070Available Now0631E400
    $2,085 October 16, 20260532B400

    Model Amenities and Features

    Features

    • Air Conditioning
    • Washer/Dryer

    Kitchen

    • Dishwasher

    Model Rent and Fees

    Model Price Range

    • $2,070 - $2,150

    Deposit

    • $2,150 deposit

    Unit 0551C Amenities and Features

    Features

    • Washer/Dryer

    Kitchen

    • Dishwasher

    Unique Features

    • Backsplash
    • Bathroom Reno
    • Quartz/Granite Counter

    Unit 0551C Rent and Fees

    Unit Price

    • $2,150
      • View Details and Rent Estimate

    Deposit

    • $2,150 deposit

    Model Rent and Fees

    Model Price Range

    • $2,070 - $2,150

    Unit 0631E Amenities and Features

    Features

    • Washer/Dryer

    Kitchen

    • Dishwasher

    Unique Features

    • Bathroom Reno

    Unit 0631E Rent and Fees

    Unit Price

    • $2,070
      • View Details and Rent Estimate

    Deposit

    • $2,150 deposit

    Model Rent and Fees

    Model Price Range

    • $2,070 - $2,150

    Unit 0532B Amenities and Features

    Features

    • Washer/Dryer

    Kitchen

    • Dishwasher

    Unique Features

    • Bathroom Reno
    • Quartz/Granite Counter

    Unit 0532B Rent and Fees

    Unit Price

    • $2,085
      • View Details and Rent Estimate

    Deposit

    • $2,150 deposit

    Model Rent and Fees

    Model Price Range

    • $2,070 - $2,150

  • 1 Bedroom

    Floorplan A1

    From $2,300

    1 Bed, 1 Bath, 550-665 sq ft
    Available Now

    Model Gallery

    Floorplans

    Availability Details

    PriceAvailability DateUnitSq FtView Details
    $2,520Available Now0252A665
    $2,300Available Now0211A665
    $2,495 October 1, 20260112D665

    Model Amenities and Features

    Features

    • Air Conditioning
    • Washer/Dryer

    Model Rent and Fees

    Model Price Range

    • $2,300 - $2,590

    Current Available Pricing

    • $2,300 - $2,520

    Deposit

    • $2,590 deposit

    Unit 0252A Amenities and Features

    Features

    • Washer/Dryer

    Unique Features

    • Bathroom Reno
    • Quartz/Granite Counter

    Unit 0252A Rent and Fees

    Unit Price

    • $2,520
      • View Details and Rent Estimate

    Deposit

    • $2,590 deposit

    Model Rent and Fees

    Model Price Range

    • $2,300 - $2,590

    Unit 0211A Amenities and Features

    Features

    • Washer/Dryer

    Unit 0211A Rent and Fees

    Unit Price

    • $2,300
      • View Details and Rent Estimate

    Deposit

    • $2,590 deposit

    Model Rent and Fees

    Model Price Range

    • $2,300 - $2,590

    Unit 0112D Amenities and Features

    Features

    • Washer/Dryer

    Unique Features

    • Bathroom Reno
    • Quartz/Granite Counter

    Unit 0112D Rent and Fees

    Unit Price

    • $2,495
      • View Details and Rent Estimate

    Deposit

    • $2,590 deposit

    Model Rent and Fees

    Model Price Range

    • $2,300 - $2,590

    Floorplan A2

    1 Bed, 1 Bath, 705 sq ft
    Available Soon

    Model Gallery

    Floorplans

    Availability Details

    Availability DateUnitSq Ft
    Available SoonA2705 sq ft

    Model Amenities and Features

    Features

    • Air Conditioning
    • Washer/Dryer

  • 2 Bedrooms

    Floorplan B1

    From $2,690

    2 Beds, 1 Bath, 820 sq ft
    Available Now
    Cheapest 2 BedroomThis is the cheapest 2 Bedroom at this Property

    Model Gallery

    Floorplans

    Availability Details

    PriceAvailability DateUnitSq FtView Details
    $2,770Available Now0252B820
    $2,960Available Now0172B820
    $2,960Available Now0072B820

    Model Amenities and Features

    Features

    • Air Conditioning
    • Washer/Dryer

    Model Rent and Fees

    Model Price Range

    • $2,690 - $2,960

    Current Available Pricing

    • $2,770 - $2,960

    Deposit

    • $2,960 deposit

    Unit 0252B Amenities and Features

    Features

    • Washer/Dryer

    Unit 0252B Rent and Fees

    Unit Price

    • $2,770
      • View Details and Rent Estimate

    Deposit

    • $2,960 deposit

    Model Rent and Fees

    Model Price Range

    • $2,690 - $2,960

    Unit 0172B Amenities and Features

    Features

    • Washer/Dryer

    Unique Features

    • Bathroom Reno

    Unit 0172B Rent and Fees

    Unit Price

    • $2,960
      • View Details and Rent Estimate

    Deposit

    • $2,960 deposit

    Model Rent and Fees

    Model Price Range

    • $2,690 - $2,960

    Unit 0072B Amenities and Features

    Features

    • Washer/Dryer

    Unique Features

    • Quartz/Granite Counter

    Unit 0072B Rent and Fees

    Unit Price

    • $2,960
      • View Details and Rent Estimate

    Deposit

    • $2,960 deposit

    Model Rent and Fees

    Model Price Range

    • $2,690 - $2,960

    Floorplan B5

    From $2,735

    2 Beds, 1 Bath, 915 sq ft
    Available Now
    Largest 2 BedroomThis is the largest 2 Bedroom at this Property

    Model Gallery

    Floorplans

    Availability Details

    PriceAvailability DateUnitSq FtView Details
    $3,110Available Now0691C915
    $2,735Available Now0711B915

    Model Amenities and Features

    Features

    • Washer/Dryer

    Model Rent and Fees

    Model Price Range

    • $2,735 - $3,110

    Deposit

    • $3,110 deposit

    Unit 0691C Amenities and Features

    Features

    • Washer/Dryer

    Unique Features

    • Bathroom Reno
    • Quartz/Granite Counter

    Unit 0691C Rent and Fees

    Unit Price

    • $3,110
      • View Details and Rent Estimate

    Deposit

    • $3,110 deposit

    Model Rent and Fees

    Model Price Range

    • $2,735 - $3,110

    Unit 0711B Amenities and Features

    Features

    • Washer/Dryer

    Unit 0711B Rent and Fees

    Unit Price

    • $2,735
      • View Details and Rent Estimate

    Deposit

    • $3,110 deposit

    Model Rent and Fees

    Model Price Range

    • $2,735 - $3,110

    Floorplan B2

    $2,750

    2 Beds, 1 Bath, 840 sq ft
    Available Now

    Model Gallery

    Floorplans

    Availability Details

    PriceAvailability DateUnitSq Ft
    $2,750Available Now0692B840

    Unit 0692B Amenities and Features

    Features

    • Washer/Dryer

    Unit 0692B Rent and Fees

    Unit Price

    • $2,750
      • View Details and Rent Estimate

    Deposit

    • $2,750 deposit

    Model Rent and Fees

    Price

    • $2,750

    Floorplan B4

    From $2,800

    2 Beds, 1.5 Baths, 875 sq ft
    Available Oct 3

    Model Gallery

    Floorplans

    Photos

    Availability Details

    PriceAvailability DateUnitSq FtView Details
    $2,800 October 3, 20260152B875
    $3,180 December 15, 20260251C875

    Model Amenities and Features

    Features

    • Air Conditioning
    • Washer/Dryer

    Model Rent and Fees

    Model Price Range

    • $2,800 - $3,180

    Deposit

    • $3,180 deposit

    Unit 0152B Amenities and Features

    Features

    • Washer/Dryer

    Unit 0152B Rent and Fees

    Unit Price

    • $2,800
      • View Details and Rent Estimate

    Deposit

    • $3,180 deposit

    Model Rent and Fees

    Model Price Range

    • $2,800 - $3,180

    Unit 0251C Amenities and Features

    Features

    • Washer/Dryer

    Unique Features

    • Backsplash
    • Bathroom Reno
    • Quartz/Granite Counter

    Unit 0251C Rent and Fees

    Unit Price

    • $3,180
      • View Details and Rent Estimate

    Deposit

    • $3,180 deposit

    Model Rent and Fees

    Model Price Range

    • $2,800 - $3,180

    Floorplan B3

    2 Beds, 1 Bath, 870 sq ft
    Available Soon

    Model Gallery

    Floorplans

    Availability Details

    Availability DateUnitSq Ft
    Available SoonB3870 sq ft

    Model Amenities and Features

    Features

    • Air Conditioning
    • Washer/Dryer
Price shown is base rent. Excludes user-selected optional fees and variable or usage-based fees and required charges due at or prior to move-in or at move-out. View Fees and Policies for details. Price, availability, fees, and any applicable rent special are subject to change without notice.

Schedule a Tour

Request Tour
Call us at: (934) 333-5378 to request a tour.

3D Tours

2BR,1BA - 840SF
2BR,1.5BA - 875SF
2BR,1.5BA -87SF
1BR,1BA -840SF

Property Information

  • 232 Units
  • 2 Stories
  • Built in 1965

Lease Terms

  • 12 mo
  • Short Term Lease Options
Ask About Our Lease Terms

Fees and Policies

The fees listed below are community-provided and may exclude utilities or add-ons. All payments are made directly to the property and are non-refundable unless otherwise specified. Use the Cost Calculator to determine costs based on your needs.

Ask About Our Fees

Required Fees

One-Time Basics

Due at Application
Application Fee (Per Applicant)iCharged per applicant.$20.00
Due at Move-In
Utility - Setup FeeiCharged Per Unit.$10.00

Utilities

Utility - Billing Administrative FeeiCharged Per Unit.$5.00/mo

Other Fees and Policies

Personal Add-Ons

Renter's InsuranceiCharged Per Unit.$14.00/mo
Replacement - Mailbox KeyiCharged per unit.$50.00
Replacement - Access DeviceiCharged per unit.$50.00
Lock Change FeeiCharged per unit.$200.00
Clean Sweep FeeiCharged per unit.$400.00

Situational Fees

Late FeeiCharged Per Unit.$50.00
Violation - LeaseiCharged Per Unit.$75.00
Returned Payment FeeiCharged Per Unit.$75.00
Violation - TrashiCharged Per Unit.$100.00
Lock Out FeeiCharged Per Unit.$100.00
Community Transfer FeeiCharged Per Unit.$1,000.00

Pet Fees

Cat
One-Time Pet FeeiMax of 2. Charged Per Pet.$250.00
Monthly Pet FeeiMax of 2. Charged Per Pet.$50.00
25 lbs. Weight Limit
Comments:

Max of 2. Cats welcome. Maximum two pets per apartment. Monthly fees: $25 per cat. Non-refundable fee: $300 per pet. Breed restrictions and other limitations apply. Weight limit: 35 lbs. Other restrictions may apply.

Dog
Monthly Pet FeeiMax of 2. Charged Per Pet.$50.00
One-Time Pet FeeiMax of 2. Charged Per Pet.$250.00
40 lbs. Weight Limit
Restrictions:

Breed Restrictions Apply. Please visit the website to view our Pet Policy.

Comments:

Max of 2. Dogs welcome. Maximum two pets per apartment. Monthly fees: $50 per dog. Non-refundable fee: $300 per pet. Breed restrictions and other limitations apply. Weight limit: 35 lbs.

Fish
    Restrictions:

    breed restrictions

    Parking Fees

    Surface Lot
    Parking FeeiMax of 1. Charged Per Vehicle.$50.00/mo
    Comments:

    Max of 1. Parking Available.

    Property Fee Disclaimer: Based on community-supplied data and independent market research. Subject to change without notice. May exclude fees for mandatory or optional services and usage-based utilities.

    Features and Amenities

    On-Site Services

    • Maintenance On Site
    • Property Manager On Site
    • Laundry Facilities

    Community Features

    • Corporate Housing
    • Walk Up

    Recreation and Fitness

    • Playground

    Interior Features

    • Storage Space
    • Heating
    • Ceiling Fans
    • High Speed Internet Access
    • Washer/Dryer
    • Air Conditioning
    • Smoke Free

    Kitchen Amenities

    • Stainless Steel Appliances
    • Dishwasher
    • Range
    • Refrigerator
    • Microwave

    Living Area Features

    • Walk In Closets
    • Hardwood Floors
    Ask About Our Amenities
    Google Map

    Map

    35 Penataquit Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706
    Schedule a Time to Come See Us

    Getting Around

    • 60 / 100 Moderately walkable

      Most day-to-day needs are within walking distance

    • 30 / 100 Limited public transit

      Transit is available for some trips

    • 30 / 100 Somewhat Bikeable

      Not very suitable for bicycle commuting and/or recreation

    • 70 / 100 Moderately car friendly

      Good access to freeways and/or major arteries, with a low chance of parking problems

    Scores provided by Local Logic details

    Getting to Know the Area

    • 80 / 100 Restaurants

      Wide variety of restaurants within a few minutes

    • 60 / 100 Cafes

      Variety of cafés within a few minutes

    • 80 / 100 Nightlife

      Wide variety of bars within a few minutes

    • 70 / 100 Shopping

      Several shops within a few minutes

    • 20 / 100 Noise Level

      Multiple sources of noise nearby

    Scores provided by Local Logic

    Frequently Asked Questions about Mid Island Apartments

    Where is Mid Island Apartments located?

    Mid Island Apartments is located at 35 Penataquit Ave near the Downtown Bay Shore area of Bay Shore, NY

    What is the current rent range at Mid Island Apartments?

    Studio to 2 Bedroom Apartments at Mid Island Apartments currently range from $2,070 to $3,180

    When is the leasing office open?

    • The office Hours for Mid Island Apartments are
    • Monday 9:00 am–5:30 pm
    • Tuesday 9:00 am–5:30 pm
    • Wednesday 9:00 am–5:30 pm
    • Thursday 9:00 am–5:30 pm
    • Friday 9:00 am–5:30 pm
    • Saturday 9:00 am–5:30 pm
    • Sunday Closed

    Are pets allowed?

    Call us today to find out our pet policy and if we allow pets

    Lifestyle Ratings

    • Affordability Nice Value3.2

      The Mid Island Apartments Apartments are 14.7% cheaper than the average apartment in the Downtown Bay Shore area.

      Rent Comparison to the Downtown Bay Shore Neighborhood

      FloorplanLowest Price HereNeighborhood Avg RentNbhd Avg RentCost Difference%
      Studio$2,070$2,219-$149-6.7%
      1 Bedroom$2,300$2,697-$397-14.7%
      2 Bedroom$2,690$3,478-$788-22.7%

      Methodology: On 09/18/2026, ApartmentHomeLiving.com compared current rents by floorplan to 124 other apartment communities in the immediate area around Mid Island Apartments (Downtown Bay Shore) using today’s up-to-date pricing using the sum/count averaging formula. This data will be updated in real-time as prices fluctuate.

      Rent Pricing Data as of 09/18/2026

    Learn more about Lifestyle Search

    Renters Reviews and Ratings

    3.0
    2 Renters Reviews

    Just don’t live here.

    March 23, 2024 - Review from Apartments.com
    I regret to say that my experience living at this apartment complex has been thoroughly disappointing. The incessant noise from neighbors makes it nearly impossible to relax or concentrate. Additionally, the lack of consistent hot water is unacceptable and makes daily routines uncomfortable. Despite numerous attempts to contact the leasing office about these issues, their lack of responsiveness only adds to the frustration. Overall, I cannot recommend this apartment complex to anyone seeking a ...
    peaceful and comfortable living environment.
    Read More

    Property Manager Responded

    March 27, 2024
    Afton D., Thank you for sharing your feedback with us. We sincerely apologize for the disappointing experience you've had during your time at our apartment complex. We understand the frustrations with the ongoing water issue. Our team has been actively working to resolve the hot water issue, and while temporary solutions have been implemented, we are working towards a permanent solution. We are committed to continuing our efforts until this issue is fully resolved. Regarding noise disturbances, we understand how disruptive this can be to your daily life. While we don't have any notes in your tenant history regarding noise complaints, we take your feedback seriously and will take additional steps to address this matter promptly. We apologize if there have been any lapses in responsiveness from our leasing office. We strive to provide excellent customer service to all our residents, and we regret any instances where we may have fallen short. Your satisfaction is important to us, and ...
    we would appreciate the opportunity to discuss your concerns further and work towards finding solutions. Please feel free to reach out to us directly so that we can assist you in any way possible.

    Excited!

    September 17, 2020 - Review from Apartments.com
    Couldn't be happier with Mark! Moving in soon....he made himself available quickly & answered all my questions. Apartment finishes are gorgeous! Will review again after I move in

    Property Manager Responded

    November 12, 2020
    Dear Valued Resident, we're glad you had such a wonderful experience with our Property Manager, Mark! Our team strives to deliver an excellent experience, and are glad you found this to be the case during your visit. If you have further needs or questions, please reach out! All our best, Mid Island Apartments

    Nearby Schools

    Brook Avenue Elementary School

    Bay Shore Union Free School District
    45 Brook Avenue
    Public School - Grades K-5 (336 Students)
    In Attendance Zone1 minute drive / 0.6 miles away

    Bay Shore Senior High School

    Bay Shore Union Free School District
    155 Third Avenue
    Public School - Grades 9-12 (1862 Students)
    In Attendance Zone2 minute drive / 0.9 miles away
    6/10

    Gardiner Manor School

    Bay Shore Union Free School District
    125 Wohseepee Drive
    Public School - Grades K-5 (739 Students)
    In Attendance Zone4 minute drive / 2.1 miles away
    3/10

    Bay Shore Middle School

    Bay Shore Union Free School District
    393 Brook Avenue
    Public School - Grades 6-8 (1258 Students)
    In Attendance Zone3 minute drive / 1.3 miles away
    5/10
    Contact Us About Nearby Schools
    School data provided by GreatSchools.
    details
    The GreatSchools Rating helps parents compare schools within a state based on a variety of school quality indicators and provides a helpful picture of how effectively each school serves all of its students. Ratings are on scale of 1 (below average) and to 10 (above average) and can include test scores, college readiness, academic progress, advanced courses, equity, discipline and attendance data. We also advise parents to visit schools, consider other information on school performance and programs, and consider needs as part of the school selection process.

    About GreatSchools Data on ApartmentHomeLiving.com.

    Points of Interest

    Time and distance from Mid Island Apartments.

    Big Box and Retail

    Target

    838 Sunrise Hwy
    5 minute drive / 1.94 miles away

    Lowe's

    800 Sunrise Hwy
    4 minute drive / 2.18 miles away

    Walgreens

    26 Wicks Rd
    7 minute drive / 3.51 miles away

    Colleges and Universities

    Touro University - Law Center

    225 Eastview Drive
    7 minute drive / 3.32 miles away

    SUNY Suffolk County Community College - Michael J. Grant Campus

    Crooked Hill Road
    10 minute drive / 4.97 miles away

    Farmingdale State College

    2350 Broadhollow Road
    21 minute drive / 10.03 miles away

    Groceries

    Shoprite

    1 Garet Pl
    12 minute drive / 5.95 miles away

    Trader Joe's

    2085 New Moriches Rd
    24 minute drive / 11.22 miles away

    Hospitals

    Southside Hospital

    301 East Main Street
    1 minute drive / 0.36 miles away

    Good Samaritan Hospital Medical Center

    1000 Montauk Highway
    7 minute drive / 3.34 miles away

    Pilgrim Psychiatric Center

    998 Crooked Hill Road
    12 minute drive / 5.68 miles away

    Shopping Centers

    South Shore Plaza

    1746-1766 Sunrise Hwy
    1 minute drive / 0.48 miles away

    Bay Shore Commons

    533-605 Montauk Hwy
    1 minute drive / 0.53 miles away

    Promenade at Bay Shore

    1675 Sunrise Hwy
    1 minute drive / 0.62 miles away

    Mid Island Apartments has 5 shopping centers within 0.7 miles.

    Transit Stations

    Bay Shore Station-Montauk Branch

    2 minute drive / 0.82 miles away

    Islip Station-Montauk Branch

    4 minute drive / 1.66 miles away

    Brentwood Station-Ronkonkoma Branch

    7 minute drive / 3.52 miles away

    Nearby Neighborhoods

    Downtown Bay Shore

    Studio to 3 Bedroom Apartments from $1,970
    View Rentals

    West Bay Shore

    Studio to 3 Bedroom Apartments from $1,500
    View Rentals

    Brightwaters Farm

    Studio to 3 Bedroom Apartments from $1,850
    View Rentals

    Rental Price Ranges in the Area

    BedroomAverage RentCheapest RentHighest Rent
    Bay Shore Studio Apartments $2,219$1,970$3,024
    Bay Shore 1 Bedroom Apartments $2,596$1,500$3,956
    Bay Shore 2 Bedroom Apartments $3,318$1,966$6,537
    Bay Shore 3 Bedroom Apartments $4,056$3,000$5,894
    2 Bedroom Homes$3,037$1,900$4,000
    3 Bedroom Homes$5,335$2,850$10,000+
    4 Bedroom Homes$5,187$4,500$6,000
    5 Bedroom Homes$11,875$8,000$10,000+

    Browse Top Apartments in Bay Shore

    By Price

    By Community Type

    By Amenities

    Viewing: Mid Island Apartments | Desktop Version | Listing Updated: 09/17/2026 | AHLPLA