Skip to main content

Find Your Perfect Place

Montauk, NY
11954 Apartments
Homes

Favorites

Your message has been sent! Thank you!

Homes for Rent in the 11954 ZIP Code of Montauk, NY with Hardwood Floors (0 Rentals)

Choose Your Rental

Bedrooms

How Many Bedrooms?Done

All
1 Bed
4 Bed
5 Bed

More

Price

Select your price rangeDone

to

Lifestyle

Lifestyle Matching SearchDone

Pet Friendly
Family Friendly
Active Lifestyle
Outdoors
Student Living
Accessibility
Eco-Friendly
55+ Active Adult
Work From Home
Transit Friendly
Combined Lifestyle Rating

Learn more about Lifestyle Search

Amenities (1)

By AmenitiesDone

Allows Pets
Air Conditioning
Fitness Center
Garage
Hardwood Floors
Laundry Room
Parking
Playground
Smoke Free Options
Swimming Pool
Washer/Dryer

Community Types

By Community TypeDone

Controlled Access
Garden

Done

Happy puppy

Woof!

No results for that search query.

Enjoy this photo of a really happy pup and try fetching from other Homes options.

Refine Your Search

Apartments for rent in Montauk, NY

Browse Homes for Rent in the 11954 Zip Code of Montauk

By Amenities

11954 Pet Friendly Homes for Rent

By Price

11954 Luxury Homes for Rent

By Community Type

Montauk Apartments for Rent
11954 Homes for Rent
11954 Apartments for Rent
11954 Condos for Rent

Tell Us What You Think About Montauk

Are you an expert on Montauk?

If so, our renters would love to know what your favorite things are that make it shine. Tell us what you love (and don't) about Montauk.

Parks
Entertainment
Local Vibes
Restaurants
Location
Traffic
Public Transportation
Outdoor Access
Cost of Living
Safety

Please enter a rating or review

First Name*Cannot be emptyMust be 2-25 characters

How many years have you lived here? (optional)

10+

5-10

2-5

0-2

Comments (optional)(0/1000)Maximum 1000 characters

By clicking submit I agree to the Apartments.com Terms of Service and the Ratings & Reviews Terms of Use.

Thanks for your review!

Your review of Montauk has been submitted!

We'll check your Montauk review to ensure it meets our Review Guidelines.

Thank you!

Viewing: Homes in 11954 in Montauk, NY | Zip Code Listings | desktop Version | Last Updated: 07/29/2026

Equal Housing Opportunity
About Us
Contact Us
Sitemap

Terms of Service
Privacy Notice
Exercise Your Privacy Rights
Avoid Scams and Fraud

Lifestyle Search Methodology
Accessibility
Cookie Policy

© 2026 CoStar Group, Inc.