56 Carroll St

About 56 Carroll St

Sag Harbor Jewel Box - Minutes to Village, Heated Saltwater Pool The Wildflower: A Designer-Owned Sag Harbor Farmhouse, Quiet Luxury Reimagined A rare and refined offering in Sag Harbor, The Wildflower is a designer-owned 1900s farmhouse that has undergone a considered, top-to-bottom renovation completed in January 2026. The home reflects a high level of material integrity and thoughtful detailing seldom found on the rental market-where historic character meets a modern, editorial sensibility. The Property & Grounds Approached via a long, private gravel drive, the home presents a classic Hamptons silhouette, finished in James Hardie plank siding and framed by mature landscaping. The entire property is enclosed by tall, established hedges on all sides, creating a sense of privacy and seclusion rarely found this close to Sag Harbor Village. A 20' x 40' heated saltwater pool anchors the outdoor living experience and serves as the natural focal point of the property. Outdoor living is central to the home's design: bluestone patios, furnished with curated pieces from Restoration Hardware and Arhaus, create inviting settings for poolside lounging, outdoor dining, and relaxed entertaining. As daylight fades, professional landscape lighting softly illuminates the gardens, transforming the half-acre property into a quiet, private retreat. The interiors are defined by clean architectural lines, custom mahogany millwork, and a restrained palette that allows the home's proportions and natural light to take center stage. The renovation emphasizes cohesion and longevity over excess, resulting in spaces that feel edited, warm, and inherently livable. The kitchen is a refined and functional centerpiece, featuring Bas Stone Italian marble, custom cabinetry, a professional ILVE range, and Miele appliances. Unlacquered brass fixtures and hardware from deVOL Kitchens and Rejuvenation add depth and character designed to evolve gracefully over time. Subtle, intentional touches-such as vintage lighting sourced from France and Italy and unlacquered brass toggle switches throughout the home-underscore the designer's eye without overpowering the farmhouse setting. A newly created mudroom offers custom storage and a brand-new LG washer and dryer, ideal for beach days, pool use, and extended summer stays. With four bedrooms and three full baths, the home balances ease of living with privacy. The Primary Suite is a calm retreat featuring a king-size bed and a beautifully appointed en-suite bath with Bas Stone marble, Waterworks fixtures, and herringbone white oak flooring, adding warmth and distinction. The Garden Suite is a main-floor bedroom opens directly to the pool terrace through double glass doors, creating effortless indoor-outdoor flow. All bedrooms are equipped with blackout curtains, central air conditioning, and smart climate control for comfortable, quiet nights. Each bathroom is finished with custom marble sinks and Waterworks unlacquered brass hardware, offering a consistent and elevated experience throughout the home. High-speed Wi-Fi and a smart television ensure the house is as easy to live in as it is thoughtfully designed. The Location The Wildflower offers a rare balance of privacy and proximity. Minutes to Sag Harbor Village: Just a short drive to the American Hotel, Le Bilboquet, Bay Street Theater, marinas, boutiques, and dining. Conveniently positioned for Bridgehampton, East Hampton, and the area's most sought-after beaches, farm stands and world class dining and shopping. The Wildflower is not about scale-it is about intention. A home designed for those who value privacy, restraint, and thoughtful design over excess. Available for Summer 2026, The Wildflower offers a rare chance to experience Sag Harbor as it was meant to be lived-private, considered, and quietly refined. Registration Code: RP252108 [[Rental Registration # RP252108]] EH RR #: RP252108

56 Carroll St is located in the Outlying Eastern Suffolk Neighborhood and 11963 Zip code of Sag Harbor, NY.

Property Contact Info

Contact: Jaime Richichi

Call Us: (516) 749-5242

Features and Amenities

Map

• Shopping
• Schools
• Grocery
• Medical
• Transportation

Map

Explore Nearby

Shopping

Schools

Grocery

Medical

Transportation

Frequently Asked Questions about 56 Carroll St