Fire Island, New York Neighborhoods and Nearby Cities

No results found
Try different search terms.

Other Neighborhoods near Fire Island, NY

AP

Argyle Park

4.0 stars
Affordability
View ApartmentsStudio - 5 Bedroom
$1,200 to $26,700
48 Apartments1 Rental
A

Arista

3.5 stars
Affordability
View ApartmentsStudio - 3 Bedroom
$2,000 to $6,890
37 Apartments19 Rentals
A

Asharoken

View Apartments1 - 1 Bedroom
$3,375 to $3,520
2 Apartments4 Rentals
B

Baywood

4.0 stars
Family Friendly
View ApartmentsStudio - 3 Bedroom
$1,558 to $14,792
82 Apartments0 Rentals
BT

Belle Terre

3.0 stars
Affordability
View ApartmentsStudio - 3 Bedroom
$1,600 to $5,568
35 Apartments2 Rentals
BG

Birchwood Glen

4.0 stars
Affordability
View ApartmentsStudio - 3 Bedroom
$1,500 to $5,709
122 Apartments7 Rentals
BF

Brightwaters Farm

4.0 stars
Affordability
View ApartmentsStudio - 3 Bedroom
$1,000 to $14,792
164 Apartments16 Rentals
BD

Business District

4.0 stars
Active Lifestyle
View ApartmentsStudio - 5 Bedroom
$1,200 to $26,700
71 Apartments6 Rentals
C

Caledonia

4.0 stars
Affordability
View ApartmentsStudio - 3 Bedroom
$2,000 to $6,890
48 Apartments22 Rentals
CS

Candy Section

4.0 stars
Affordability
View ApartmentsStudio - 3 Bedroom
$1,850 to $5,900
39 Apartments12 Rentals
CF

Central Fire Island

View Apartments1 - 2 Bedroom
$18,000 to $32,000
4 Apartments17 Rentals
CS

Central Suffolk

4.0 stars
Affordability
View ApartmentsStudio - 7 Bedroom
$990 to $32,000
521 Apartments244 Rentals
CN

Commack North

4.0 stars
Affordability
View ApartmentsStudio - 3 Bedroom
$1,700 to $5,900
54 Apartments12 Rentals
CB

Copper Beech Village

3.5 stars
Affordability
View ApartmentsStudio - 3 Bedroom
$1,500 to $5,709
51 Apartments3 Rentals
CC

Courthouse Commons

4.0 stars
Affordability
View ApartmentsStudio - 7 Bedroom
$1,000 to $8,000
121 Apartments16 Rentals
DR

Deer Run

3.5 stars
Affordability
View ApartmentsStudio - 3 Bedroom
$1,000 to $3,475
49 Apartments8 Rentals
DB

Downtown Bay Shore

4.0 stars
Affordability
View ApartmentsStudio - 3 Bedroom
$1,000 to $14,792
100 Apartments5 Rentals
DR

Downtown Riverhead

View ApartmentsStudio - 3 Bedroom
$976 to $3,700
27 Apartments0 Rentals
East Patchogue

East Patchogue

4.0 stars
Affordability
View ApartmentsStudio - 3 Bedroom
$1,200 to $5,709
41 Apartments8 Rentals
ES

East Shoreham

3.0 stars
Affordability
View Apartments1 - 1 Bedroom
$2,200 to $2,400
5 Apartments6 Rentals
EF

Eastern Fire Island

3.5 stars
Affordability
View ApartmentsStudio - 3 Bedroom
$1,200 to $5,709
62 Apartments26 Rentals
EN

Eatons Neck

View Apartments1 - 1 Bedroom
$3,000 to $3,520
12 Apartments0 Rentals
E

Elwood

4.0 stars
Affordability
View ApartmentsStudio - 2 Bedroom
$2,000 to $5,900
21 Apartments3 Rentals
FC

Five Corners

3.5 stars
Family Friendly
View ApartmentsStudio - 3 Bedroom
$1,750 to $4,554
38 Apartments1 Rental
FH

Fort Hill

4.0 stars
Affordability
View ApartmentsStudio - 3 Bedroom
$2,350 to $7,000
37 Apartments10 Rentals
FS

Fort Salonga

4.0 stars
Affordability
View Apartments1 - 2 Bedroom
$1,700 to $3,500
50 Apartments13 Rentals
FS

Fred Shores

4.0 stars
Active Lifestyle
View ApartmentsStudio - 5 Bedroom
$1,200 to $26,700
105 Apartments13 Rentals
GO

Gilgo Oak Beach Captree

View Apartments1 - 1 Bedroom
$2,300 to $2,500
2 Apartments2 Rentals
GH

Gordon Heights

4.0 stars
Affordability
View ApartmentsStudio - 3 Bedroom
$990 to $4,119
28 Apartments3 Rentals
H

Halesite

3.5 stars
Affordability
View Apartments1 - 3 Bedroom
$2,495 to $7,000
51 Apartments3 Rentals
HO

Head of the Harbor

4.0 stars
Affordability
View ApartmentsStudio - 2 Bedroom
$2,000 to $3,175
10 Apartments3 Rentals
HB

Huntington Bay

View Apartments1 - 3 Bedroom
$2,400 to $7,000
32 Apartments0 Rentals
IT

Islip Terrace

4.0 stars
Affordability
View ApartmentsStudio - 7 Bedroom
$1,550 to $8,000
67 Apartments0 Rentals
LR

Lake Ronkonkoma

4.0 stars
Affordability
View ApartmentsStudio - 3 Bedroom
$1,750 to $7,192
64 Apartments19 Rentals
Lake Ronkonkoma

Lake Ronkonkoma

3.0 stars
Affordability
View ApartmentsStudio - 3 Bedroom
$1,750 to $4,554
36 Apartments8 Rentals
LW

Lakeview Woods

4.0 stars
Affordability
View ApartmentsStudio - 3 Bedroom
$1,500 to $5,709
166 Apartments9 Rentals
M

Mayfair

4.0 stars
Affordability
View ApartmentsStudio - 3 Bedroom
$1,850 to $5,900
19 Apartments2 Rentals
N

Nissequogue

3.0 stars
Affordability
View ApartmentsStudio - 2 Bedroom
$2,150 to $3,175
8 Apartments4 Rentals
North Amityville

North Amityville

4.0 stars
Affordability
View ApartmentsStudio - 3 Bedroom
$1,750 to $6,024
46 Apartments2 Rentals
NB

North Bay Shore

3.0 stars
Active Lifestyle
View ApartmentsStudio - 3 Bedroom
$1,550 to $14,792
64 Apartments3 Rentals
North Bellport

North Bellport

4.0 stars
Affordability
View Apartments1 - 3 Bedroom
$1,200 to $4,219
16 Apartments2 Rentals
ND

North Deer Park

4.0 stars
Affordability
View ApartmentsStudio - 3 Bedroom
$1,139 to $3,600
34 Apartments6 Rentals
NG

North Great River

4.0 stars
Affordability
View ApartmentsStudio - 3 Bedroom
$1,500 to $5,040
52 Apartments0 Rentals
NG

North Great River

4.0 stars
Affordability
View ApartmentsStudio - 3 Bedroom
$1,500 to $5,040
51 Apartments0 Rentals
NL

North Lindenhurst

4.0 stars
Affordability
View ApartmentsStudio - 3 Bedroom
$1,750 to $26,700
52 Apartments2 Rentals
NP

North Patchogue

4.0 stars
Active Lifestyle
View ApartmentsStudio - 3 Bedroom
$1,500 to $5,709
62 Apartments0 Rentals
NS

North Smithtown

4.0 stars
Family Friendly
View ApartmentsStudio - 3 Bedroom
$2,000 to $4,160
23 Apartments1 Rental
OF

Old Field

View Apartments1 - 3 Bedroom
$1,600 to $3,900
3 Apartments2 Rentals
PR

Poospatuck Reservation

4.0 stars
Cost Per Square Foot
View Apartments1 - 3 Bedroom
$1,550 to $5,800
18 Apartments0 Rentals
P

Poquott

4.0 stars
Active Lifestyle
View ApartmentsStudio - 3 Bedroom
$1,600 to $5,568
37 Apartments3 Rentals
PS

Presidential Section

4.0 stars
Active Lifestyle
View ApartmentsStudio - 5 Bedroom
$1,200 to $26,700
75 Apartments14 Rentals
SE

Setauket East Setauket

4.0 stars
Affordability
View Apartments1 - 3 Bedroom
$1,600 to $5,761
55 Apartments15 Rentals
SH

South Huntington

View Apartments1 - 3 Bedroom
$2,000 to $6,890
40 Apartments6 Rentals
SS

Southwestern Suffolk

4.0 stars
Active Lifestyle
View ApartmentsStudio - 7 Bedroom
$1,000 to $32,000
423 Apartments207 Rentals
SJ

St James

4.0 stars
Active Lifestyle
View ApartmentsStudio - 3 Bedroom
$2,000 to $4,160
20 Apartments7 Rentals
S

Summerfield

4.0 stars
Affordability
View ApartmentsStudio - 3 Bedroom
$990 to $4,310
108 Apartments6 Rentals
T

Terryville

4.0 stars
Affordability
View ApartmentsStudio - 3 Bedroom
$1,250 to $6,363
52 Apartments8 Rentals
TC

The Colony

4.0 stars
Affordability
View ApartmentsStudio - 3 Bedroom
$1,500 to $5,709
118 Apartments7 Rentals
TV

The Villages at Mount Sinai Park

4.0 stars
Affordability
View ApartmentsStudio - 3 Bedroom
$1,250 to $6,363
48 Apartments24 Rentals
V

Vanderbilt

3.0 stars
Affordability
View ApartmentsStudio - 3 Bedroom
$1,850 to $5,900
19 Apartments11 Rentals
VH

VIllage Hill

3.0 stars
Affordability
View ApartmentsStudio - 3 Bedroom
$1,850 to $5,900
19 Apartments12 Rentals
VO

Village of the Branch

4.0 stars
Pet Friendly
View ApartmentsStudio - 3 Bedroom
$2,095 to $4,160
22 Apartments1 Rental
WB

West Bay Shore

3.5 stars
Affordability
View ApartmentsStudio - 3 Bedroom
$1,300 to $14,792
56 Apartments5 Rentals
WH

West Hampton Dunes

View Apartments
$500
2 Apartments11 Rentals
WS

West Side

4.0 stars
Affordability
View ApartmentsStudio - 3 Bedroom
$1,139 to $3,600
56 Apartments22 Rentals
WF

Western Fire Island

View Apartments2 - 7 Bedroom
$5,000 to $32,000
19 Apartments143 Rentals
WS

Western Suffolk

4.0 stars
Active Lifestyle
View ApartmentsStudio - 7 Bedroom
$1,000 to $26,700
601 Apartments170 Rentals
WP

Westhampton Pines

View Apartments1 - 6 Bedroom
$2,300 to $65,000
19 Apartments156 Rentals
WH

Wheatley Heights

4.0 stars
Affordability
View ApartmentsStudio - 3 Bedroom
$1,139 to $5,505
21 Apartments4 Rentals
W

Wyandanch

4.0 stars
Affordability
View ApartmentsStudio - 3 Bedroom
$1,139 to $5,505
25 Apartments6 Rentals

Expert Rental Resources

Helpful Apartment Articles, How-To's and Tips

The rental experts at ApartmentHomeLiving.com provide you with top advice, tools, and tips for understanding the leasing process and finding the perfect rental. Here are a few helpful rental and leasing articles from our experts to guide you on your search.

decorative image for Roommate Matching: Finding the Right Fit and Avoiding Pitfalls article

Roommate Matching: Finding the Right Fit and Avoiding Pitfalls

Written by: Cheryl Bowman

A fantastic way to save money and enjoy a built-in community is to share an apartment. However, a bad roommate situation can turn your dream rental into a nightmare.

decorative image for The Art of the Rental Viewing: What to look for during a property tour article

The Art of the Rental Viewing: What to look for during a property tour

Written by: Marie Brown

You’ve scrolled through countless listings, walked through a blur of rentals, and finally found what feels like the one. The pictures? Fantastic. The neighborhood seems just right.

decorative image for Know Your Budget: Calculating What You Can Realistically Afford When Renting article

Know Your Budget: Calculating What You Can Realistically Afford When Renting

Written by: Lauren Harrington

Renting an apartment or house isn’t just about looking through online ads, choosing a few apartments or homes you want to tour, filling out an application, and putting down a deposit. Those things are all necessary and important.

decorative image for The Freedom of Short-Term Leases: Exploring the Advantages for Renters article

The Freedom of Short-Term Leases: Exploring the Advantages for Renters

Written by: Bobbi Jackson

If you’re looking to relocate right now, a popular solution that may best fit your current rental needs is a short-term lease.