4 Bay Ave

Shelter Island, NY 11964
(631) 888-6327
Check Availability

Photos

Contact

4 Bay Ave

4 Bay Ave
Shelter Island, NY 11964
(631) 888-6327
4 Bay Ave in Shelter Island, NY - Building Photo
5 Bedroom - Home for Rent
  • 5BR, 4BAHome
  • $55,000Price
  • Available NowAvailability

About 4 Bay Ave

This clean and modern harborfront home is located in an area that features glorious sunsets. There are lovely gardens and shade trees with meditation areas to read or relax in, and the main home offers an open floor plan, with an L-shaped living room that maximizes views of the water, a fireplace for chilly nights, dining area overlooking the water, and efficient kitchen. There is a first floor master suite as well. The second floor offers the main master suite with commanding water views, office, fireplace and spa-like bath that has direct sunset views. A guest cottage adjacent offers an office/library, living area, kitchenette, full bath and loft sleeping space. The dock will make boaters jump for joy--with 3.5 feet at low mean tide. There are two kayaks as well. Easy to love! [[Rental Registration # 2025-L-0038]]

Property Contact Info

Contact: Theresa R. Andrew

Features and Amenities

On-Site Services

  • Package Service
  • Laundry Facilities
  • Garden Style

Outdoor Features

  • Controlled Access

Interior Features

  • Air Conditioning

Pet Policy

  • No Pets Allowed
Google Map

Map

4 Bay Ave, Shelter Island, NY 11964

Frequently Asked Questions about 4 Bay Ave

Where is 4 Bay Ave located?

4 Bay Ave is located at 4 Bay Ave near the Outlying Eastern Suffolk area of Shelter Island, NY

What is the current rent range at 4 Bay Ave?

5 Bedrooms at 4 Bay Ave is $55,000. Call today for more info!

Are pets allowed?

Call us today to find out our pet policy and if we allow pets

Nearby Schools

Shelter Island School

Shelter Island Union Free
33 North Ferry Road
Public School - Grades PK-12 (174 Students)
In Attendance Zone3 minute drive / 1.3 miles away
5/10
School data provided by GreatSchools.
details
The GreatSchools Rating helps parents compare schools within a state based on a variety of school quality indicators and provides a helpful picture of how effectively each school serves all of its students. Ratings are on scale of 1 (below average) and to 10 (above average) and can include test scores, college readiness, academic progress, advanced courses, equity, discipline and attendance data. We also advise parents to visit schools, consider other information on school performance and programs, and consider needs as part of the school selection process.

About GreatSchools Data on ApartmentHomeLiving.com.

Points of Interest

Time and distance from 4 Bay Ave.

Big Box and Retail

Sleepy's
71 Montauk Hwy
21 minute drive / 9.92 miles away

Groceries

Iga
101 South St
7 minute drive / 3.72 miles away
Stop & Shop
67 Newtown Ln
22 minute drive / 10.34 miles away

Hospitals

Stony Brook Eastern Long Island Hospital
201 Manor Place
9 minute drive / 4.25 miles away

Shopping Centers

2488 Montauk Hwy
17 minute drive / 8.16 miles away
2004-2104 Montauk Hwy
17 minute drive / 8.19 miles away
352-354 Montauk Hwy
18 minute drive / 8.85 miles away

4 Bay Ave has 5 shopping centers within 9.6 miles.

Transit Stations

7 minute drive / 3.5 miles away
9 minute drive / 4.21 miles away
16 minute drive / 7.93 miles away

Nearby Neighborhoods

Studio to 7 Bedroom Apartments from $1,890
View Rentals
Studio to 7 Bedroom Apartments from $800
View Rentals

Rental Price Ranges in the Area

BedroomAverage RentCheapest RentHighest Rent
Shelter Island Studio Apartments $1,545$1,225$3,092
Shelter Island 1 Bedroom Apartments $2,070$905$6,492
Shelter Island 2 Bedroom Apartments $2,427$1,100$10,000+
Shelter Island 3 Bedroom Apartments $24,302$1,905$10,000+

Browse Top Apartments in Shelter Island

By Price

By Community Type

By Amenities

Viewing: 4 Bay Ave | Desktop Version | Listing Updated: 05/10/2025