Looking for the perfect rental? From apartments and condos to lofts and single family rentals, explore the unique pros and cons of each rental type to help you land in your perfect new place.
Looking for the perfect new rental? Learn great ways to spot the perfect apartment for you, identify common red flags, and avoid rental issues and scams with these expert provided actionable tips.
From theft to fire to water damage, the unexpected can happen to any renter. Discover why renters insurance is one of the smartest and most affordable investments you can make as a tenant.
Finding the right apartment starts with three things: location, cost, and amenities. Get the insider perspective from a real estate professional on how to nail all three.
Sharing a lease? Learn how to set clear expectations with your roommates on routines, bills, and cleaning to ensure a successful and peaceful shared living arrangement.
| Bedroom | Average Rent | Cheapest Rent | Highest Rent |
|---|---|---|---|
| Shelter Island Studio Apartments | $2,086 | $1,664 | $3,000 |
| Shelter Island 1 Bedroom Apartments | $2,234 | $1,100 | $3,752 |
| Shelter Island 2 Bedroom Apartments | $2,524 | $1,200 | $4,763 |
| Shelter Island 3 Bedroom Apartments | $3,159 | $1,400 | $3,815 |
The largest available 2 Bedroom apartment unit in Shelter Island, NY is found at 60 Mansfield Road Phase II in the New London neighborhood and is 2,365 square feet priced from $3,822. The Edgewater in the South Lyme neighborhood has the second largest 2 Bedroom, which is sized at 1,420 square feet and currently listed start at $2,835. Here is today’s list of the largest available 2 Bedroom units in Shelter Island:
| Apartment Listing | Model Name | Square Footage | Priced From |
|---|---|---|---|
| 60 Mansfield Road Phase II | 2 Bedroom w/ Den - 3A | 2,365 Sq Ft | $3,822 |
| The Edgewater | Sailfish | 1,420 Sq Ft | $2,835 |
| Washington Street Apartments | 2 BR/ 2 BA | 1,400 Sq Ft | $2,000 |
| Hanford Commons | 2BD 2BA + Office | 1,373 Sq Ft | $3,500 |
| East End LI | 2x2 | 1,358 Sq Ft | $4,000 |
| Brookside Commons | 2 bedroom - 80% | 1,197 Sq Ft | $2,066 |
| 60 Mansfield Road | Style 10 | 1,124 Sq Ft | $3,029 |
| The Sound at Gateway Commons | The Waterford | 1,115 Sq Ft | $2,645 |
| Crocker House | 2B/1B | 1,100 Sq Ft | $1,100 |
| 120 Broad St | 2 Bed/2Ba | 918 Sq Ft | $2,850 |
As of September 23, 2026 the lowest priced 2 Bedroom apartment unit in Shelter Island, NY is the 2B/1B Model starting from $1,100 at Crocker House in the New London neighborhood. The second most affordable Shelter Island 2 Bedroom is the Two Bedroom Model at Pride Point and Progress Point starting at $1,200 . The average price for all 2 Bedroom apartments in Shelter Island is currently $2,524. Here is today’s list of the cheapest available 2 Bedroom options in Shelter Island:
| Apartment Listing | Model Name | Priced From |
|---|---|---|
| Crocker House | 2B/1B | $1,100 |
| Pride Point and Progress Point | Two Bedroom | $1,200 |
| Eagle Pointe | TWO BEDROOM | $1,730 |
| Bayonet Street Apartments | Bayo II - Two Bed Two Bath | $1,750 |
| Nutmeg Woods | The Birch | $1,783 |
| 70 Pond Meadow Rd | 2 Bedroom | $1,800 |
| Sutton Place | REMODELED 2BD WD in unit | $2,000 |
| Washington Street Apartments | 2 BR/ 2 BA | $2,000 |
| Brookside Commons | 2 bedroom - 80% | $2,066 |
| 12 Sharaf St | 2 Beds / 1 Bath | $2,100 |
Entering the rental market? Learn these simple tips and strategies to avoid common pitfalls and make confident choices. Rent with peace of mind.
Read ArticleFrom the letter A all the way to the letter Z, the Real Estate and Rental Term Glossary from the content team at ApartmentHomeLiving.com provides our visitors and shoppers with a little clarity and helpful guidance in navigating the real estate world through definitions and explainers for the top subjects and terms that someone may come across during the leasing, buying, or selling process.
Read ArticleThe common "Rule of Thumb" is that rent should be no more than 30% of your income. How much is that? Enter your monthly income and click "Calculate My Budget" to find out.
If you’re an expert on all things Shelter Island, tell us what you love (and don't) by rating it and writing a review.
Write a ReviewSee the most popular apartments and homes in Shelter Island, NY
Currently the most affordable 2 Bedroom in Shelter Island is at Crocker House listed at $1,100.
The average rent for a 2 Bedroom Apartment in Shelter Island is $2,524.
Today's apartment with the most square footage in Shelter Island is a 2,365 square feet unit starting from $3,822 at 60 Mansfield Road Phase II.
The average size for a 2 Bedroom rental in Shelter Island is currently 1,006 sq ft.
The rental experts at ApartmentHomeLiving.com provide you with top advice, tools, and tips for understanding the leasing process and finding the perfect rental. Here are a few helpful rental and leasing articles from our experts to guide you on your search.
Written by: Robin Stewart
Where do you see yourself? When you think of home, sweet home, are you in a 3/2 apartment? Dreaming of a tall townhome? Maybe an industrial loft heavy on cool vibes is on your visioning board.
Written by: Robin Stewart
Many housing markets throughout America share a common complaint: a lack of affordable rental properties.
Written by: Robin Stewart
Renters want to find a great apartment, the right place for them, one that checks all the boxes of location, rental cost, amenities, safety, and more.
Written by: Robin Stewart
Hindsight is 20/20. Live and Learn. With age comes wisdom. We’re familiar with all those expressions, and all of them apply to lessons first-time renters learn.
We'll check your Shelter Island review to ensure it meets our Review Guidelines.
Thank you!
