5161 Caroline Ave

Check Availability
Indianapolis, IN 46205

Photos

Contact

5161 Caroline Ave

Indianapolis, IN 46205
5161 Caroline Ave in Indianapolis, IN - Building Photo
2 Bedroom - Townhome for Rent
  • 2BR, 1BATownhome
  • $1,200Pricing
  • 1,200Square Feet
  • Available NowAvailability

Schedule a Tour

Schedule a Tour

About 5161 Caroline Ave

Two-bedroom duplex in South Broad Ripple. Hardwood floors and freshly painted interior. The windows are older. Walking distance to Planet Fitness, Aldi, Half-Liter and the Speakeasy. Large, unfinished basement. Quiet street and great neighbors. Apply today - these go really fast. Please note: I get 100 applications when these units go up. If you are interested, please include a short note about why this house would be a good fit for you and who all will be living there. There aren't many options for a 2-bedroom in this price range in Broad Ripple, so typically these rent within a week or two. We are going to take our time and pick the best fit for the area and the neighborhood. Professional, conscientious, community-oriented people is our goal. We appreciate what diversity has brought to our community. We happily invite people of any gender, orientation, religion, race, background, etc. to apply to our properties. The unit has older windows, but is well kept-up for an older house. There will be a background check and credit check. No, you cannot run a dog grooming company or daycare out of the house. Lawn maintenance is included with this rental. Pets negotiable based on breed.

5161 Caroline Ave is located in the Fairgrounds Neighborhood and 46205 Zip code of Indianapolis, IN.

Property Contact Info

Contact: Leslie Scaggs

Lease Terms

  • 12 Month Lease

Fees and Policies

Pet Policy and Fees

Cats

Allowed

Dogs

Allowed

Parking Info and Fees

Street

Property Fee Disclaimer: Based on community-supplied data and independent market research. Subject to change without notice. May exclude fees for mandatory or optional services and usage-based utilities.

Features and Amenities

On-Site Services

  • Day Care

Interior Features

  • Storage Space
  • Ceiling Fans
  • Heating
  • Tub/Shower
  • Cable Ready
  • Washer/Dryer Hookup
  • Wi Fi

Kitchen Amenities

  • Range

Living Area Features

  • Basement
  • Hardwood Floors

Outdoor Features

  • Lawn
Google Map

Map

5161 Caroline Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46205

Frequently Asked Questions about 5161 Caroline Ave

What type of rentals are available at 5161 Caroline Ave?

There is currently a 2 Bed 1 Bath Townhome for rent with 1,200 listed at 5161 Caroline Ave. It is Available Now.

How much is the rent at 5161 Caroline Ave?

5161 Caroline Ave is currently listed at $1,200.

What area of town is 5161 Caroline Ave located in?

Located in the Fairgrounds Neighborhood, 5161 Caroline Ave is in the 46205 Zip Code of Indianapolis, IN.

Lifestyle Ratings

  • Cost Per Sq.Ft. 3.4

    The Cost Per Square Foot rating shows you the average cost per square foot for floorplans at this community in relation to the local average.

  • Affordability 3.2

    The Affordability rating shows you how this community's most affordable floorplan pricing relates to the local average.

Learn more about Lifestyle Search

Nearby Schools

Shortridge High School

Indianapolis Public Schools
3401 North Meridian Street
Public School - Grades 9-12 (0 Students)
2/10

Rousseau McClellan School 91

Indianapolis Public Schools
5111 Evanston Avenue
Public School - Grades PK-8 (0 Students)
6/10

Arsenal Technical High School

Indianapolis Public Schools
1500 E Michigan St
Public School - Grades 9-12 (0 Students)
1/10

Eliza A. Blaker School 55

Indianapolis Public Schools
1349 East 54th Street
Public School - Grades PK-8 (0 Students)
3/10
School data provided by GreatSchools.
details
The GreatSchools Rating helps parents compare schools within a state based on a variety of school quality indicators and provides a helpful picture of how effectively each school serves all of its students. Ratings are on scale of 1 (below average) and to 10 (above average) and can include test scores, college readiness, academic progress, advanced courses, equity, discipline and attendance data. We also advise parents to visit schools, consider other information on school performance and programs, and consider needs as part of the school selection process.

About GreatSchools Data on ApartmentHomeLiving.com.

Points of Interest

Time and distance from 5161 Caroline Ave.

Arts Museums and Landmarks

Children's Museum of Indianapolis

3000 N. Meridian St.
6 minute drive / 3.09 miles away

Indianapolis Museum of Art

4000 Michigan Road
6 minute drive / 3.2 miles away

Indianapolis Museum of Contemporary Art

340 N. Senate Avenue
12 minute drive / 5.67 miles away

Big Box and Retail

Lowe's

6002 N Rural St
3 minute drive / 1.16 miles away

Safeway

5602 N Illinois St
4 minute drive / 1.62 miles away

Goodwill

3058-3124 E 39th St
5 minute drive / 1.87 miles away

Colleges and Universities

Butler University

4600 Sunset Ave
4 minute drive / 2.22 miles away

Ivy Tech Community College - Downtown Indianapolis Campus

50 West Fall Creek Pkwy
7 minute drive / 3.49 miles away

Marian University

3200 Cold Spring Rd
9 minute drive / 4.46 miles away

Groceries

The Fresh Market

5415 N College Ave
2 minute drive / 0.81 miles away

Safeway

5602 N Illinois St
4 minute drive / 1.62 miles away

Save-A-Lot

2930 E 38th St
5 minute drive / 1.84 miles away

Hospitals

Indiana University Health

1701 N Senate Blvd
9 minute drive / 4.51 miles away

Options Behavioral Health System

5602 Caito Drive
9 minute drive / 4.61 miles away

Neurodiagnostic Institute

5435 E 16th St
10 minute drive / 5.09 miles away

Military Bases

Naval Avionics Center

11 minute drive / 5.44 miles away

Parks and Recreation

SpaceQuest Planetarium

3000 N Meridian St
6 minute drive / 3.09 miles away

Benjamin Harrison House

1230 North Delaware Street
10 minute drive / 4.76 miles away

White River State Park

White River State Park
13 minute drive / 6.2 miles away

5161 Caroline Ave has 5 parks within 7.0 miles, including SpaceQuest Planetarium, Benjamin Harrison House, White River State Park, Climb Time Indy, and Caribbean Cove.

Restaurants and Dining

H20 Sushi

1912 Broad Ripple Avenue
3 minute drive / 1.3 miles away

3 Sisters Cafe

6360 N. Guilford Ave
4 minute drive / 1.66 miles away

Elements

415 North Alabama Street
11 minute drive / 5.45 miles away

Shopping Centers

SoBro Spirits Plaza

1701-1721 E 52nd St
1 minute drive / 0.2 miles away

54th Place Shoppes

2170-2198 E 54th St
1 minute drive / 0.28 miles away

Keystone Plaza

2240-2346 E 52nd St
1 minute drive / 0.33 miles away

5161 Caroline Ave has 5 shopping centers within 0.5 miles.

Nearby Neighborhoods

Studio to 3 Bedroom Apartments from $775
View Rentals
Studio to 3 Bedroom Apartments from $649
View Rentals
Studio to 6 Bedroom Apartments from $629
View Rentals

Nearby Apartments

Rental Price Ranges in the Area

BedroomAverage RentCheapest RentHighest Rent
Indianapolis Studio Apartments $1,164$595$4,858
Indianapolis 1 Bedroom Apartments $1,376$497$4,657
Indianapolis 2 Bedroom Apartments $1,638$563$6,546
Indianapolis 3 Bedroom Apartments $2,063$870$8,552
Indianapolis 4 Bedroom Apartments $2,069$600$10,000+
Indianapolis 5 Bedroom Apartments $7,889$900$10,000+

Browse Top Apartments in Indianapolis

Viewing: 5161 Caroline Ave | Desktop Version | Listing Updated: 01/28/2026

Applying has never been easier!

The property you are applying to at 5161 Caroline Ave uses the Apartments.com application portal.