1100 7th St
GreenportNY11944
Apartments for Rent in Shelter Island, NY (90 Rentals) Page 2 of 2
517 Flint St
GreenportNY11944
248 5th Ave
GreenportNY11944
424 4th St
GreenportNY11944
220 Fiddler Ln
GreenportNY11944
336 2nd St
GreenportNY11944
131 6th St
GreenportNY11944
8 Oyster Pt
GreenportNY11944
1510 Maple Ln
GreenportNY11944
165 Marine Pl
GreenportNY11944
3650 Bay Shore Rd
GreenportNY11944
750 Kerwin Blvd
GreenportNY11944
312 5th Ave
GreenportNY11944
185 Inlet Ln
GreenportNY11944
237 6th St
GreenportNY11944
446 6th St
GreenportNY11944
134 6th St
GreenportNY11944
40 Stirling Cove
GreenportNY11944
35 Bayberry Ln
Sag HarborNY11963
18 S Harbor Dr
Sag HarborNY11963
68 W Water St
Sag HarborNY11963
189 Main St
Sag HarborNY11963
465 Tarpon Dr
SoutholdNY11971
950 Blue Marlin Dr
SoutholdNY11971
24 Forest Crossing
SagaponackNY11962
close
View Me
1 to 2 Bedroom Apartments
61 Bank St
61 Bank StNew London, CT 06320
close
View Me
1 Bedroom Apartments
1 S Ferry Rd
1 S Ferry RdShelter Island, NY 11964
close
View Me
Studio Apartments
Driftwood Cove
1000 9th StGreenport, NY 11944
close
View Me
Studio Apartments
Oyster Point
30 Oyster PtGreenport, NY 11944
close
View Me
Studio Apartments
370 Ferry Rd
370 Ferry RdSag Harbor, NY 11963
close
View Me
Studio Apartments
256 Elm St
256 Elm StSouthampton, NY 11968
close
View Me
1 to 2 Bedroom Apartments
The Grand
9-15 John StClinton, CT 06413
close
View Me
1 to 2 Bedroom Apartments
Bay Point Apartments
468 Main StNiantic, CT 06357
close
View Me
1 to 2 Bedroom Apartments
26 Sunset Ter
26 Sunset TerEssex, CT 06426
close
View Me
Studio Apartments
8 Bank St
8 Bank StNew London, CT 06320
close
View Me
1 Bedroom Apartments
Garfield Avenue Apartments
145 Garfield AveNew London, CT 06320
close
View Me
Studio to 2 Bedroom Apartments
Villages at Shore Landing
5 Nob Hill RdNew London, CT 06320
close
View Me
Studio to 2 Bedroom Apartments
120 Broad St
120 Broad StNew London, CT 06320
close
View Me
Studio to 2 Bedroom Apartments
Highland Apartments
43 Granite StNew London, CT 06320
close
View Me
1 Bedroom Apartments
Avery Heights Senior Living
300 Brandegee AveGroton, CT 06340
Showing Results 51-90, Page 2 of 2
Shelter Island, NY Local Guide
House on Shelter Island by Peter Bond is licensed under CC BY 2.0
How much does it cost to rent an apartment in Shelter Island?
| Bedroom | Average Rent | Cheapest Rent | Highest Rent |
|---|---|---|---|
| Shelter Island Studio Apartments | $2,016 | $1,604 | $2,474 |
| Shelter Island 1 Bedroom Apartments | $2,179 | $1,100 | $3,830 |
| Shelter Island 2 Bedroom Apartments | $2,508 | $1,200 | $4,928 |
| Shelter Island 3 Bedroom Apartments | $3,067 | $1,400 | $3,815 |
Note: Properties with the Total Monthly Price badge include all required fees. Hover over the badge for details.
How much does it cost to rent a home in Shelter Island?
| Bedroom | Average Rent | Cheapest Rent | Highest Rent |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2 Bedroom Homes | $9,940 | $3,200 | $10,000+ |
| 3 Bedroom Homes | $23,550 | $3,750 | $10,000+ |
| 4 Bedroom Homes | $23,330 | $4,500 | $10,000+ |
| 6 Bedroom Homes | $54,000 | $10,000 | $10,000+ |
Note: Properties with the Total Monthly Price badge include all required fees. Hover over the badge for details.
Browse Top Apartments in Shelter Island
Explore Shelter Island
Let everyone know!
Do you know the Shelter Island area?
If you’re an expert on all things Shelter Island, tell us what you love (and don't) by rating it and writing a review.
Write a Review
Frequently Asked Questions about Shelter Island
What is the current pricing and availability for apartments for rent in Shelter Island, NY?
As of today, September 08, 2026, there are currently 90 available Shelter Island apartments priced from $1,100 to $4,928, with an average monthly rent of $2,360.
How much are Studio apartments in Shelter Island?
There are currently 19 Studio Apartments in Shelter Island with rent ranges from $1,604 to $2,474 with an average price of $2,016.
What is the current price range for One Bedroom Shelter Island Apartments for rent?
Today's rental pricing for One Bedroom Apartments in Shelter Island ranges from $1,100 to $3,830 with an average monthly rent of $2,179.
What does renting a Two Bedroom Apartment in Shelter Island cost?
The monthly rent prices of Two Bedroom Apartments currently available in Shelter Island range from $1,200 to $4,928. Today's average rental price for Two Bedrooms here is $2,508.
How expensive are Shelter Island Three Bedroom Apartments?
There are currently 8 Three Bedroom Apartments listings available in Shelter Island on ApartmentHomeLiving.com. The pricing ranges from $1,400 to $3,815 - averaging $3,067 for the location.
Expert Rental Resources
The rental experts at ApartmentHomeLiving.com provide you with top advice, tools, and tips for understanding the leasing process and finding the perfect rental. Here are a few helpful rental and leasing articles from our experts to guide you on your search.
Articles, How-To's, and Tips
Exploring Rental Options: Apartments, Townhomes, and Lofts - Oh My!
Written by: Robin Stewart
Where do you see yourself? When you think of home, sweet home, are you in a 3/2 apartment? Dreaming of a tall townhome? Maybe an industrial loft heavy on cool vibes is on your visioning board.
Practical Tips for Renters: How to Identify a Great Rental and Avoid Red Flags
Written by: Robin Stewart
Renters want to find a great apartment, the right place for them, one that checks all the boxes of location, rental cost, amenities, safety, and more.
First Apartment Regrets: Real Renters Share What They'd Do Differently
Written by: Robin Stewart
Hindsight is 20/20. Live and Learn. With age comes wisdom. We’re familiar with all those expressions, and all of them apply to lessons first-time renters learn.
Renters Insurance 101: What It Is, What It Covers, and Why You Need It
Written by: Robin Stewart
Insurance seems to be a part of life. In some states, having insurance is the law, as is the case for automobile insurance. Renters are no exception.